Why short-term experiments may not allow long-term predictions about intraguild predation

Cheryl J. Briggs, Elizabeth T. Borer

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

73 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Equilibrium models are increasingly employed in applied ecology, but often because of experimental logistics, only short-term laboratory experiments are performed. Here, we use simple models to examine the management relevance of this disconnection between theory and experiments in communities with intraguild predation (IGP). Equilibrium theory shows that IGP can promote coexistence of competitors on a shared resource. However, adding the intraguild predator can result in higher resource densities than in a system with the intraguild prey alone with its resource. This has important management implications when the shared resource is a pest species whose population is controlled by natural enemies. Our models demonstrate why short-term experiments and studies ignoring alternate resources may bear no relationship to a system at equilibrium. Short-term experiments quantifying only attack rates can predict a broad range of outcomes. By ignoring conversion efficiency, consumer longevity, and immigration, short-term studies may, for example, cause erroneous decisions about the introduction of natural enemies in biological control. Thus, attack rates, conversion efficiencies, and immigration rates must all be quantified for a thorough, long-term understanding of IGP in field systems.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)1111-1117
Number of pages7
JournalEcological Applications
Volume15
Issue number4
DOIs
StatePublished - Jan 1 2005

Fingerprint

intraguild predation
resource
prediction
natural enemy
experiment
immigration
pest species
biological control
coexistence
logistics
predator
rate

Keywords

  • Biological control
  • Closed system
  • Conversion efficiency
  • Equilibrium theory
  • Immigration
  • Invasive species

Cite this

Why short-term experiments may not allow long-term predictions about intraguild predation. / Briggs, Cheryl J.; Borer, Elizabeth T.

In: Ecological Applications, Vol. 15, No. 4, 01.01.2005, p. 1111-1117.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{a91c120d7b6045b49d44a31c0ed4ab96,
title = "Why short-term experiments may not allow long-term predictions about intraguild predation",
abstract = "Equilibrium models are increasingly employed in applied ecology, but often because of experimental logistics, only short-term laboratory experiments are performed. Here, we use simple models to examine the management relevance of this disconnection between theory and experiments in communities with intraguild predation (IGP). Equilibrium theory shows that IGP can promote coexistence of competitors on a shared resource. However, adding the intraguild predator can result in higher resource densities than in a system with the intraguild prey alone with its resource. This has important management implications when the shared resource is a pest species whose population is controlled by natural enemies. Our models demonstrate why short-term experiments and studies ignoring alternate resources may bear no relationship to a system at equilibrium. Short-term experiments quantifying only attack rates can predict a broad range of outcomes. By ignoring conversion efficiency, consumer longevity, and immigration, short-term studies may, for example, cause erroneous decisions about the introduction of natural enemies in biological control. Thus, attack rates, conversion efficiencies, and immigration rates must all be quantified for a thorough, long-term understanding of IGP in field systems.",
keywords = "Biological control, Closed system, Conversion efficiency, Equilibrium theory, Immigration, Invasive species",
author = "Briggs, {Cheryl J.} and Borer, {Elizabeth T.}",
year = "2005",
month = "1",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1890/04-1776",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "15",
pages = "1111--1117",
journal = "Ecological Appplications",
issn = "1051-0761",
publisher = "Ecological Society of America",
number = "4",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Why short-term experiments may not allow long-term predictions about intraguild predation

AU - Briggs, Cheryl J.

AU - Borer, Elizabeth T.

PY - 2005/1/1

Y1 - 2005/1/1

N2 - Equilibrium models are increasingly employed in applied ecology, but often because of experimental logistics, only short-term laboratory experiments are performed. Here, we use simple models to examine the management relevance of this disconnection between theory and experiments in communities with intraguild predation (IGP). Equilibrium theory shows that IGP can promote coexistence of competitors on a shared resource. However, adding the intraguild predator can result in higher resource densities than in a system with the intraguild prey alone with its resource. This has important management implications when the shared resource is a pest species whose population is controlled by natural enemies. Our models demonstrate why short-term experiments and studies ignoring alternate resources may bear no relationship to a system at equilibrium. Short-term experiments quantifying only attack rates can predict a broad range of outcomes. By ignoring conversion efficiency, consumer longevity, and immigration, short-term studies may, for example, cause erroneous decisions about the introduction of natural enemies in biological control. Thus, attack rates, conversion efficiencies, and immigration rates must all be quantified for a thorough, long-term understanding of IGP in field systems.

AB - Equilibrium models are increasingly employed in applied ecology, but often because of experimental logistics, only short-term laboratory experiments are performed. Here, we use simple models to examine the management relevance of this disconnection between theory and experiments in communities with intraguild predation (IGP). Equilibrium theory shows that IGP can promote coexistence of competitors on a shared resource. However, adding the intraguild predator can result in higher resource densities than in a system with the intraguild prey alone with its resource. This has important management implications when the shared resource is a pest species whose population is controlled by natural enemies. Our models demonstrate why short-term experiments and studies ignoring alternate resources may bear no relationship to a system at equilibrium. Short-term experiments quantifying only attack rates can predict a broad range of outcomes. By ignoring conversion efficiency, consumer longevity, and immigration, short-term studies may, for example, cause erroneous decisions about the introduction of natural enemies in biological control. Thus, attack rates, conversion efficiencies, and immigration rates must all be quantified for a thorough, long-term understanding of IGP in field systems.

KW - Biological control

KW - Closed system

KW - Conversion efficiency

KW - Equilibrium theory

KW - Immigration

KW - Invasive species

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=23044434497&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=23044434497&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1890/04-1776

DO - 10.1890/04-1776

M3 - Article

VL - 15

SP - 1111

EP - 1117

JO - Ecological Appplications

JF - Ecological Appplications

SN - 1051-0761

IS - 4

ER -