The settling of perforated disks in quiescent and turbulent air

The settling velocity of frozen hydrometeors in the atmospheric surface layer depends on their inertial and drag properties, and on the intensity of ambient turbulence. Thin, solid and perforated circular disks have been investigated through high-speed imaging, under laboratory conditions, to reproduce the settling of snow plates and dendrites in quiescent and turbulent flows. Different perforations made it possible to test the parameterisation of the fall speed in quiescent air, based on the geometric description of the solidity of the disk cross-sectional area. Interestingly, different falling styles, ranging from stable horizontal to fluttering and tumbling, were observed to depend significantly on the perforation geometry, which resulted in the stabilisation of the particle rotation and in a modulation of the drag coefficient. Ambient turbulence is observed to primarily induce cross-flow drag on the disks settling in the nonlinear regime, causing a reduction of the settling velocity in all cases investigated. Turbulence also manifests a secondary effect on the disk rotational dynamics, in particular when tumbling and stable falling styles co-exist, based on the phase space defined by the Reynolds number and the inertia ratio. The interaction between ambient turbulence, particle anisotropy and permeability and the likelihood of tumbling is inferred to be the main reason for the observed settling velocity variability of snow dendrites in nature.