The price of admission: does moving to a low-poverty neighborhood increase discriminatory experiences and influence mental health?

Theresa L Osypuk, Nicole M Schmidt, Rebecca D. Kehm, Eric J. Tchetgen Tchetgen, M. Maria Glymour

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Purpose: The Moving to Opportunity (MTO) study is typically interpreted as a trial of changes in neighborhood poverty. However, the program may have also increased exposure to housing discrimination. Few prior studies have tested whether interpersonal and institutional forms of discrimination may have offsetting effects on mental health, particularly using intervention designs. Methods: We evaluated the effects of MTO, which randomized public housing residents in 5 cities to rental vouchers, or to in-place controls (N = 4248, 1997–2002), which generated variation on neighborhood poverty (% of residents in poverty) and encounters with housing discrimination. Using instrumental variable analysis (IV), we derived two-stage least squares IV estimates of effects of neighborhood poverty and housing discrimination on adult psychological distress and major depressive disorder (MDD). Results: Randomization to voucher group vs. control simultaneously decreased neighborhood % poverty and increased exposure to housing discrimination. Higher neighborhood % poverty was associated with increased psychological distress [B IV = 0.36, 95% confidence interval (CI) 0.03, 0.69] and MDD (B IV = 0.12, 95% CI − 0.005, 0.25). Effects of housing discrimination on mental health were harmful, but imprecise (distress B IV = 1.58, 95% CI − 0.83, 3.99; MDD B IV = 0.57, 95% CI − 0.43, 1.56). Because neighborhood poverty and housing discrimination had offsetting effects, omitting either mechanism from the IV model substantially biased the estimated effect of the other towards the null. Conclusions: Neighborhood poverty mediated MTO treatment on adult mental health, suggesting that greater neighborhood poverty contributes to mental health problems. Yet housing discrimination-mental health findings were inconclusive. Effects of neighborhood poverty on health may be underestimated when failing to account for discrimination.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)181-190
Number of pages10
JournalSocial Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology
Volume54
Issue number2
DOIs
StatePublished - Feb 12 2019

Fingerprint

Poverty
Mental Health
mental health
discrimination
poverty
housing
experience
Major Depressive Disorder
confidence
Confidence Intervals
Public Housing
resident
Psychology
public housing
model analysis
Random Allocation
Least-Squares Analysis
Health

Keywords

  • Discrimination
  • Housing
  • Neighborhood poverty
  • Psychological distress
  • Randomized controlled trial

PubMed: MeSH publication types

  • Journal Article
  • Randomized Controlled Trial

Cite this

The price of admission : does moving to a low-poverty neighborhood increase discriminatory experiences and influence mental health? / Osypuk, Theresa L; Schmidt, Nicole M; Kehm, Rebecca D.; Tchetgen Tchetgen, Eric J.; Glymour, M. Maria.

In: Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology, Vol. 54, No. 2, 12.02.2019, p. 181-190.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{b09b5e91af1b4f8ca526987c40aa61ff,
title = "The price of admission: does moving to a low-poverty neighborhood increase discriminatory experiences and influence mental health?",
abstract = "Purpose: The Moving to Opportunity (MTO) study is typically interpreted as a trial of changes in neighborhood poverty. However, the program may have also increased exposure to housing discrimination. Few prior studies have tested whether interpersonal and institutional forms of discrimination may have offsetting effects on mental health, particularly using intervention designs. Methods: We evaluated the effects of MTO, which randomized public housing residents in 5 cities to rental vouchers, or to in-place controls (N = 4248, 1997–2002), which generated variation on neighborhood poverty ({\%} of residents in poverty) and encounters with housing discrimination. Using instrumental variable analysis (IV), we derived two-stage least squares IV estimates of effects of neighborhood poverty and housing discrimination on adult psychological distress and major depressive disorder (MDD). Results: Randomization to voucher group vs. control simultaneously decreased neighborhood {\%} poverty and increased exposure to housing discrimination. Higher neighborhood {\%} poverty was associated with increased psychological distress [B IV = 0.36, 95{\%} confidence interval (CI) 0.03, 0.69] and MDD (B IV = 0.12, 95{\%} CI − 0.005, 0.25). Effects of housing discrimination on mental health were harmful, but imprecise (distress B IV = 1.58, 95{\%} CI − 0.83, 3.99; MDD B IV = 0.57, 95{\%} CI − 0.43, 1.56). Because neighborhood poverty and housing discrimination had offsetting effects, omitting either mechanism from the IV model substantially biased the estimated effect of the other towards the null. Conclusions: Neighborhood poverty mediated MTO treatment on adult mental health, suggesting that greater neighborhood poverty contributes to mental health problems. Yet housing discrimination-mental health findings were inconclusive. Effects of neighborhood poverty on health may be underestimated when failing to account for discrimination.",
keywords = "Discrimination, Housing, Neighborhood poverty, Psychological distress, Randomized controlled trial",
author = "Osypuk, {Theresa L} and Schmidt, {Nicole M} and Kehm, {Rebecca D.} and {Tchetgen Tchetgen}, {Eric J.} and Glymour, {M. Maria}",
year = "2019",
month = "2",
day = "12",
doi = "10.1007/s00127-018-1592-0",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "54",
pages = "181--190",
journal = "Social Psychiatry",
issn = "0037-7813",
publisher = "D. Steinkopff-Verlag",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - The price of admission

T2 - does moving to a low-poverty neighborhood increase discriminatory experiences and influence mental health?

AU - Osypuk, Theresa L

AU - Schmidt, Nicole M

AU - Kehm, Rebecca D.

AU - Tchetgen Tchetgen, Eric J.

AU - Glymour, M. Maria

PY - 2019/2/12

Y1 - 2019/2/12

N2 - Purpose: The Moving to Opportunity (MTO) study is typically interpreted as a trial of changes in neighborhood poverty. However, the program may have also increased exposure to housing discrimination. Few prior studies have tested whether interpersonal and institutional forms of discrimination may have offsetting effects on mental health, particularly using intervention designs. Methods: We evaluated the effects of MTO, which randomized public housing residents in 5 cities to rental vouchers, or to in-place controls (N = 4248, 1997–2002), which generated variation on neighborhood poverty (% of residents in poverty) and encounters with housing discrimination. Using instrumental variable analysis (IV), we derived two-stage least squares IV estimates of effects of neighborhood poverty and housing discrimination on adult psychological distress and major depressive disorder (MDD). Results: Randomization to voucher group vs. control simultaneously decreased neighborhood % poverty and increased exposure to housing discrimination. Higher neighborhood % poverty was associated with increased psychological distress [B IV = 0.36, 95% confidence interval (CI) 0.03, 0.69] and MDD (B IV = 0.12, 95% CI − 0.005, 0.25). Effects of housing discrimination on mental health were harmful, but imprecise (distress B IV = 1.58, 95% CI − 0.83, 3.99; MDD B IV = 0.57, 95% CI − 0.43, 1.56). Because neighborhood poverty and housing discrimination had offsetting effects, omitting either mechanism from the IV model substantially biased the estimated effect of the other towards the null. Conclusions: Neighborhood poverty mediated MTO treatment on adult mental health, suggesting that greater neighborhood poverty contributes to mental health problems. Yet housing discrimination-mental health findings were inconclusive. Effects of neighborhood poverty on health may be underestimated when failing to account for discrimination.

AB - Purpose: The Moving to Opportunity (MTO) study is typically interpreted as a trial of changes in neighborhood poverty. However, the program may have also increased exposure to housing discrimination. Few prior studies have tested whether interpersonal and institutional forms of discrimination may have offsetting effects on mental health, particularly using intervention designs. Methods: We evaluated the effects of MTO, which randomized public housing residents in 5 cities to rental vouchers, or to in-place controls (N = 4248, 1997–2002), which generated variation on neighborhood poverty (% of residents in poverty) and encounters with housing discrimination. Using instrumental variable analysis (IV), we derived two-stage least squares IV estimates of effects of neighborhood poverty and housing discrimination on adult psychological distress and major depressive disorder (MDD). Results: Randomization to voucher group vs. control simultaneously decreased neighborhood % poverty and increased exposure to housing discrimination. Higher neighborhood % poverty was associated with increased psychological distress [B IV = 0.36, 95% confidence interval (CI) 0.03, 0.69] and MDD (B IV = 0.12, 95% CI − 0.005, 0.25). Effects of housing discrimination on mental health were harmful, but imprecise (distress B IV = 1.58, 95% CI − 0.83, 3.99; MDD B IV = 0.57, 95% CI − 0.43, 1.56). Because neighborhood poverty and housing discrimination had offsetting effects, omitting either mechanism from the IV model substantially biased the estimated effect of the other towards the null. Conclusions: Neighborhood poverty mediated MTO treatment on adult mental health, suggesting that greater neighborhood poverty contributes to mental health problems. Yet housing discrimination-mental health findings were inconclusive. Effects of neighborhood poverty on health may be underestimated when failing to account for discrimination.

KW - Discrimination

KW - Housing

KW - Neighborhood poverty

KW - Psychological distress

KW - Randomized controlled trial

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85053258423&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85053258423&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1007/s00127-018-1592-0

DO - 10.1007/s00127-018-1592-0

M3 - Article

VL - 54

SP - 181

EP - 190

JO - Social Psychiatry

JF - Social Psychiatry

SN - 0037-7813

IS - 2

ER -