The extrapolation problem and how population modeling can help

Valery E. Forbes, Peter Calow, Richard M. Sibly

Research output: Contribution to journalReview article

113 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

We argue that population modeling can add value to ecological risk assessment by reducing uncertainty when extrapolating from ecotoxicological observations to relevant ecological effects. We review other methods of extrapolation, ranging from application factors to species sensitivity distributions to suborganismal (biomarker and "-omics") responses to quantitative structureactivity relationships and model ecosystems, drawing attention to the limitations of each. We suggest a simple classification of population models and critically examine each model in an extrapolation context. We conclude that population models have the potential for adding value to ecological risk assessment by incorporating better understanding of the links between individual responses and population size and structure and by incorporating greater levels of ecological complexity. A number of issues, however, need to be addressed before such models are likely to become more widely used. In a science context, these involve challenges in parameterization, questions about appropriate levels of complexity, issues concerning how specific or general the models need to be, and the extent to which interactions through competition and trophic relationships can be easily incorporated.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)1987-1994
Number of pages8
JournalEnvironmental Toxicology and Chemistry
Volume27
Issue number10
DOIs
StatePublished - Oct 1 2008

Fingerprint

population modeling
Extrapolation
Population
Population Density
Risk assessment
Uncertainty
Ecosystem
risk assessment
Biomarkers
Parameterization
Ecosystems
population structure
biomarker
population size
parameterization
ecosystem

Keywords

  • Demographic models
  • Ecological relevance
  • Ecological risk assessment
  • Individual-based models
  • Uncertainty

Cite this

The extrapolation problem and how population modeling can help. / Forbes, Valery E.; Calow, Peter; Sibly, Richard M.

In: Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry, Vol. 27, No. 10, 01.10.2008, p. 1987-1994.

Research output: Contribution to journalReview article

@article{8e76cddfaac74e60bd3fea16990120df,
title = "The extrapolation problem and how population modeling can help",
abstract = "We argue that population modeling can add value to ecological risk assessment by reducing uncertainty when extrapolating from ecotoxicological observations to relevant ecological effects. We review other methods of extrapolation, ranging from application factors to species sensitivity distributions to suborganismal (biomarker and {"}-omics{"}) responses to quantitative structureactivity relationships and model ecosystems, drawing attention to the limitations of each. We suggest a simple classification of population models and critically examine each model in an extrapolation context. We conclude that population models have the potential for adding value to ecological risk assessment by incorporating better understanding of the links between individual responses and population size and structure and by incorporating greater levels of ecological complexity. A number of issues, however, need to be addressed before such models are likely to become more widely used. In a science context, these involve challenges in parameterization, questions about appropriate levels of complexity, issues concerning how specific or general the models need to be, and the extent to which interactions through competition and trophic relationships can be easily incorporated.",
keywords = "Demographic models, Ecological relevance, Ecological risk assessment, Individual-based models, Uncertainty",
author = "Forbes, {Valery E.} and Peter Calow and Sibly, {Richard M.}",
year = "2008",
month = "10",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1897/08-029.1",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "27",
pages = "1987--1994",
journal = "Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry",
issn = "0730-7268",
publisher = "John Wiley and Sons Ltd",
number = "10",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - The extrapolation problem and how population modeling can help

AU - Forbes, Valery E.

AU - Calow, Peter

AU - Sibly, Richard M.

PY - 2008/10/1

Y1 - 2008/10/1

N2 - We argue that population modeling can add value to ecological risk assessment by reducing uncertainty when extrapolating from ecotoxicological observations to relevant ecological effects. We review other methods of extrapolation, ranging from application factors to species sensitivity distributions to suborganismal (biomarker and "-omics") responses to quantitative structureactivity relationships and model ecosystems, drawing attention to the limitations of each. We suggest a simple classification of population models and critically examine each model in an extrapolation context. We conclude that population models have the potential for adding value to ecological risk assessment by incorporating better understanding of the links between individual responses and population size and structure and by incorporating greater levels of ecological complexity. A number of issues, however, need to be addressed before such models are likely to become more widely used. In a science context, these involve challenges in parameterization, questions about appropriate levels of complexity, issues concerning how specific or general the models need to be, and the extent to which interactions through competition and trophic relationships can be easily incorporated.

AB - We argue that population modeling can add value to ecological risk assessment by reducing uncertainty when extrapolating from ecotoxicological observations to relevant ecological effects. We review other methods of extrapolation, ranging from application factors to species sensitivity distributions to suborganismal (biomarker and "-omics") responses to quantitative structureactivity relationships and model ecosystems, drawing attention to the limitations of each. We suggest a simple classification of population models and critically examine each model in an extrapolation context. We conclude that population models have the potential for adding value to ecological risk assessment by incorporating better understanding of the links between individual responses and population size and structure and by incorporating greater levels of ecological complexity. A number of issues, however, need to be addressed before such models are likely to become more widely used. In a science context, these involve challenges in parameterization, questions about appropriate levels of complexity, issues concerning how specific or general the models need to be, and the extent to which interactions through competition and trophic relationships can be easily incorporated.

KW - Demographic models

KW - Ecological relevance

KW - Ecological risk assessment

KW - Individual-based models

KW - Uncertainty

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=53949119567&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=53949119567&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1897/08-029.1

DO - 10.1897/08-029.1

M3 - Review article

C2 - 19108041

AN - SCOPUS:53949119567

VL - 27

SP - 1987

EP - 1994

JO - Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry

JF - Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry

SN - 0730-7268

IS - 10

ER -