At very high magnetic fields, GE BOLD fMRI is expected to contain nonspecific contributions and behave differently than HSE fMRI data. Similarly, the two approaches can conceivably suffer from different contributions to temporal instabilities in a times series that ultimately determine the contrast-to-noise ratio (CNR). We investigate the signal and signal fluctuation characteristics in GE and HSE fMRI data with the imaging parameters separately optimized for each contrast at 7 T. In HSE fMRI, activation-induced fractional signal change (ΔS/S) decreased rapidly, and the ratio of standard deviations of image-to-image fluctuations due to physiological processes (σ Phys) to thermal noise (σ Therm) remained constant with increasing voxel volume. In contrast, ΔS/S as well as volume of activated voxels was virtually independent of voxel size for GE BOLD, and σ Phys/σ Therm increased with increasing voxel size. The ratio of BOLD signal changes (GE/HSE) was much closer to 1 in tissue areas compared to vessel areas. These observations led to the conclusions that the spatial extent of the activation-induced ΔS/S was much broader in the GE data, and that the physiological processes that give rise to the temporal fluctuations lost coherence over millimeter distances in HSE compared to GE fMRI data. While further studies are needed to characterize it fully, σ Phys in HSE data was clearly different than in GE data. It was concluded that HSE imaging yields a significantly reduced amount of nonspecific signals compared to GE imaging, and, would be the method of choice (over GE) for high-resolution applications in humans.
Bibliographical noteFunding Information:
The authors would like to thank Drs. Peter Andersen and Gregor Adriany for hardware support. Work supported in part by the National Institutes of Health (grants P41RR08079, R01 MH70800-01, R01 EB00331, RO1MH55346, NS38295, and R21 EB00565-01), the W.M. Keck Foundation, and MIND institute. The 7-T magnet acquisition was funded in part by NSF DBI-9907842 and NIH S10 RR1395.
Copyright 2011 Elsevier B.V., All rights reserved.
- Cerebral function
- Functional mapping
- High fields