Neighborhood Opportunity and Location Affordability for Low-Income Renter Families

Dolores Acevedo-Garcia, Nancy McArdle, Erin Hardy, Keri Nicole Dillman, Jason Reece, Unda Ioana Crisan, David Norris, Theresa L. Osypuk

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

5 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

We use the Location Affordability Index (LAI) and the newly developed Child Opportunity Index (COI) to assess, for the first time, the tradeoff between neighborhood opportunity and housing/transportation affordability facing low-income renter families in the 100 largest metropolitan areas. In addition to describing the opportunity/affordability relationship, we explore the level of balance between neighborhoods’ relative cost burden and their corresponding opportunity levels to determine whether children of different racial/ethnic groups are more (or less) likely to experience cost-opportunity imbalance. Our multilevel analyses show that housing affordability is largely accounted for by the neighborhood opportunity structure within each metropolitan area. The metropolitan characteristics examined account for only a small proportion of the between-metro variance in the opportunity/affordability gradient for housing, presumably because the neighborhood opportunity structure already reflects metro area factors such as fragmentation and segregation. On the other hand, transportation affordability shows a weaker association with neighborhood opportunity. The COI/LAI association is much weaker for transportation than for housing, and a large part of the variation in the transportation gradient occurs at the metropolitan area level, not the neighborhood level. Sprawl is particularly associated with transportation affordability, with lower sprawl areas having lower transportation-cost burden. We discuss the implications of the empirical findings for defining affordability in housing assistance programs. We recommend that housing policy for low-income renter families adopt an expanded notion of affordability (housing, transportation, and opportunity) and explicitly consider equity (e.g. cost-opportunity imbalance) in the implementation of this expanded affordability definition.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)607-645
Number of pages39
JournalHousing Policy Debate
Volume26
Issue number4-5
DOIs
StatePublished - Sep 2 2016

Fingerprint

renter
low income
income
housing
metropolitan area
agglomeration area
opportunity costs
cost
housing policy
ethnic group
costs
family
equity
fragmentation
segregation
assistance
index

Keywords

  • Affordability
  • housing
  • metropolitan
  • minorities
  • neighborhood

Cite this

Acevedo-Garcia, D., McArdle, N., Hardy, E., Dillman, K. N., Reece, J., Crisan, U. I., ... Osypuk, T. L. (2016). Neighborhood Opportunity and Location Affordability for Low-Income Renter Families. Housing Policy Debate, 26(4-5), 607-645. https://doi.org/10.1080/10511482.2016.1198410

Neighborhood Opportunity and Location Affordability for Low-Income Renter Families. / Acevedo-Garcia, Dolores; McArdle, Nancy; Hardy, Erin; Dillman, Keri Nicole; Reece, Jason; Crisan, Unda Ioana; Norris, David; Osypuk, Theresa L.

In: Housing Policy Debate, Vol. 26, No. 4-5, 02.09.2016, p. 607-645.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Acevedo-Garcia, D, McArdle, N, Hardy, E, Dillman, KN, Reece, J, Crisan, UI, Norris, D & Osypuk, TL 2016, 'Neighborhood Opportunity and Location Affordability for Low-Income Renter Families', Housing Policy Debate, vol. 26, no. 4-5, pp. 607-645. https://doi.org/10.1080/10511482.2016.1198410
Acevedo-Garcia D, McArdle N, Hardy E, Dillman KN, Reece J, Crisan UI et al. Neighborhood Opportunity and Location Affordability for Low-Income Renter Families. Housing Policy Debate. 2016 Sep 2;26(4-5):607-645. https://doi.org/10.1080/10511482.2016.1198410
Acevedo-Garcia, Dolores ; McArdle, Nancy ; Hardy, Erin ; Dillman, Keri Nicole ; Reece, Jason ; Crisan, Unda Ioana ; Norris, David ; Osypuk, Theresa L. / Neighborhood Opportunity and Location Affordability for Low-Income Renter Families. In: Housing Policy Debate. 2016 ; Vol. 26, No. 4-5. pp. 607-645.
@article{38c5b0df17c44283817fd5691a5344de,
title = "Neighborhood Opportunity and Location Affordability for Low-Income Renter Families",
abstract = "We use the Location Affordability Index (LAI) and the newly developed Child Opportunity Index (COI) to assess, for the first time, the tradeoff between neighborhood opportunity and housing/transportation affordability facing low-income renter families in the 100 largest metropolitan areas. In addition to describing the opportunity/affordability relationship, we explore the level of balance between neighborhoods’ relative cost burden and their corresponding opportunity levels to determine whether children of different racial/ethnic groups are more (or less) likely to experience cost-opportunity imbalance. Our multilevel analyses show that housing affordability is largely accounted for by the neighborhood opportunity structure within each metropolitan area. The metropolitan characteristics examined account for only a small proportion of the between-metro variance in the opportunity/affordability gradient for housing, presumably because the neighborhood opportunity structure already reflects metro area factors such as fragmentation and segregation. On the other hand, transportation affordability shows a weaker association with neighborhood opportunity. The COI/LAI association is much weaker for transportation than for housing, and a large part of the variation in the transportation gradient occurs at the metropolitan area level, not the neighborhood level. Sprawl is particularly associated with transportation affordability, with lower sprawl areas having lower transportation-cost burden. We discuss the implications of the empirical findings for defining affordability in housing assistance programs. We recommend that housing policy for low-income renter families adopt an expanded notion of affordability (housing, transportation, and opportunity) and explicitly consider equity (e.g. cost-opportunity imbalance) in the implementation of this expanded affordability definition.",
keywords = "Affordability, housing, metropolitan, minorities, neighborhood",
author = "Dolores Acevedo-Garcia and Nancy McArdle and Erin Hardy and Dillman, {Keri Nicole} and Jason Reece and Crisan, {Unda Ioana} and David Norris and Osypuk, {Theresa L.}",
year = "2016",
month = "9",
day = "2",
doi = "10.1080/10511482.2016.1198410",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "26",
pages = "607--645",
journal = "Housing Policy Debate",
issn = "1051-1482",
publisher = "Taylor Graham Publishing",
number = "4-5",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Neighborhood Opportunity and Location Affordability for Low-Income Renter Families

AU - Acevedo-Garcia, Dolores

AU - McArdle, Nancy

AU - Hardy, Erin

AU - Dillman, Keri Nicole

AU - Reece, Jason

AU - Crisan, Unda Ioana

AU - Norris, David

AU - Osypuk, Theresa L.

PY - 2016/9/2

Y1 - 2016/9/2

N2 - We use the Location Affordability Index (LAI) and the newly developed Child Opportunity Index (COI) to assess, for the first time, the tradeoff between neighborhood opportunity and housing/transportation affordability facing low-income renter families in the 100 largest metropolitan areas. In addition to describing the opportunity/affordability relationship, we explore the level of balance between neighborhoods’ relative cost burden and their corresponding opportunity levels to determine whether children of different racial/ethnic groups are more (or less) likely to experience cost-opportunity imbalance. Our multilevel analyses show that housing affordability is largely accounted for by the neighborhood opportunity structure within each metropolitan area. The metropolitan characteristics examined account for only a small proportion of the between-metro variance in the opportunity/affordability gradient for housing, presumably because the neighborhood opportunity structure already reflects metro area factors such as fragmentation and segregation. On the other hand, transportation affordability shows a weaker association with neighborhood opportunity. The COI/LAI association is much weaker for transportation than for housing, and a large part of the variation in the transportation gradient occurs at the metropolitan area level, not the neighborhood level. Sprawl is particularly associated with transportation affordability, with lower sprawl areas having lower transportation-cost burden. We discuss the implications of the empirical findings for defining affordability in housing assistance programs. We recommend that housing policy for low-income renter families adopt an expanded notion of affordability (housing, transportation, and opportunity) and explicitly consider equity (e.g. cost-opportunity imbalance) in the implementation of this expanded affordability definition.

AB - We use the Location Affordability Index (LAI) and the newly developed Child Opportunity Index (COI) to assess, for the first time, the tradeoff between neighborhood opportunity and housing/transportation affordability facing low-income renter families in the 100 largest metropolitan areas. In addition to describing the opportunity/affordability relationship, we explore the level of balance between neighborhoods’ relative cost burden and their corresponding opportunity levels to determine whether children of different racial/ethnic groups are more (or less) likely to experience cost-opportunity imbalance. Our multilevel analyses show that housing affordability is largely accounted for by the neighborhood opportunity structure within each metropolitan area. The metropolitan characteristics examined account for only a small proportion of the between-metro variance in the opportunity/affordability gradient for housing, presumably because the neighborhood opportunity structure already reflects metro area factors such as fragmentation and segregation. On the other hand, transportation affordability shows a weaker association with neighborhood opportunity. The COI/LAI association is much weaker for transportation than for housing, and a large part of the variation in the transportation gradient occurs at the metropolitan area level, not the neighborhood level. Sprawl is particularly associated with transportation affordability, with lower sprawl areas having lower transportation-cost burden. We discuss the implications of the empirical findings for defining affordability in housing assistance programs. We recommend that housing policy for low-income renter families adopt an expanded notion of affordability (housing, transportation, and opportunity) and explicitly consider equity (e.g. cost-opportunity imbalance) in the implementation of this expanded affordability definition.

KW - Affordability

KW - housing

KW - metropolitan

KW - minorities

KW - neighborhood

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84983000705&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84983000705&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1080/10511482.2016.1198410

DO - 10.1080/10511482.2016.1198410

M3 - Article

C2 - 29200803

AN - SCOPUS:84983000705

VL - 26

SP - 607

EP - 645

JO - Housing Policy Debate

JF - Housing Policy Debate

SN - 1051-1482

IS - 4-5

ER -