Meta-analysis of Proportions of Rare Events–A Comparison of Exact Likelihood Methods with Robust Variance Estimation

Yan Ma, Haitao Chu, Madhu Mazumdar

Research output: Contribution to journalArticlepeer-review

25 Scopus citations


The conventional random effects model for meta-analysis of proportions approximates within-study variation using a normal distribution. Due to potential approximation bias, particularly for the estimation of rare events such as some adverse drug reactions, the conventional method is considered inferior to the exact methods based on binomial distributions. In this article, we compare two existing exact approaches—beta binomial (B-B) and normal-binomial (N-B)—through an extensive simulation study with focus on the case of rare events that are commonly encountered in medical research. In addition, we implement the empirical (“sandwich”) estimator of variance into the two models to improve the robustness of the statistical inferences. To our knowledge, it is the first such application of sandwich estimator of variance to meta-analysis of proportions. The simulation study shows that the B-B approach tends to have substantially smaller bias and mean squared error than N-B for rare events with occurrences under 5%, while N-B outperforms B-B for relatively common events. Use of the sandwich estimator of variance improves the precision of estimation for both models. We illustrate the two approaches by applying them to two published meta-analysis from the fields of orthopedic surgery and prevention of adverse drug reactions.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)3036-3052
Number of pages17
JournalCommunications in Statistics: Simulation and Computation
Issue number8
StatePublished - Sep 13 2016

Bibliographical note

Publisher Copyright:
© Taylor & Francis Group, LLC.


  • Beta-binomial
  • Meta-analysis
  • Proportions
  • Rare events


Dive into the research topics of 'Meta-analysis of Proportions of Rare Events–A Comparison of Exact Likelihood Methods with Robust Variance Estimation'. Together they form a unique fingerprint.

Cite this