Light Stable Isotopic Compositions of Enriched Mantle Sources: Resolving the Dehydration Paradox

J. E. Dixon; I. N. Bindeman; R. H. Kingsley; K. K. Simons; P. J. Le Roux; T. R. Hajewski; P. Swart; C. H. Langmuir; J. G. Ryan; K. J. Walowski; I. Wada; P. J. Wallace

doi:10.1002/2016GC006743

Light Stable Isotopic Compositions of Enriched Mantle Sources: Resolving the Dehydration Paradox

J. E. Dixon, I. N. Bindeman, R. H. Kingsley, K. K. Simons, P. J. Le Roux, T. R. Hajewski, P. Swart, C. H. Langmuir, J. G. Ryan, K. J. Walowski, I. Wada, P. J. Wallace

Earth and Environmental Sciences-Twin Cities

Research output: Contribution to journal › Article › peer-review

59 Scopus citations

Abstract

Volatile and stable isotope data provide tests of mantle processes that give rise to mantle heterogeneity. New data on enriched mid-oceanic ridge basalts (MORB) show a diversity of enriched components. Pacific PREMA-type basalts (H₂O/Ce = 215 ± 30, δD_SMOW = −45 ± 5 ‰) are similar to those in the northern Atlantic (H₂O/Ce = 220 ± 30; δD_SMOW = −30 to −40 ‰). Basalts with EM-type signatures have regionally variable volatile compositions. Northern Atlantic EM-type basalts are wetter (H₂O/Ce = 330 ± 30) and have isotopically heavier hydrogen (δD_SMOW = −57 ± 5 ‰) than northern Atlantic MORB. Southern Atlantic EM-type basalts are damp (H₂O/Ce = 120 ± 10) with intermediate δD_SMOW (−68 ± 2 ‰), similar to δD_SMOW for Pacific MORB. Northern Pacific EM-type basalts are dry (H₂O/Ce = 110 ± 20) and isotopically light (δD_SMOW = −94 ± 3 ‰). A multistage metasomatic and melting model accounts for the origin of the enriched components by extending the subduction factory concept down through the mantle transition zone, with slab temperature a key variable. Volatiles and their stable isotopes are decoupled from lithophile elements, reflecting primary dehydration of the slab followed by secondary rehydration, infiltration, and re-equilibration by fluids derived from dehydrating subcrustal hydrous phases (e.g., antigorite) in cooler, deeper parts of the slab. Enriched mantle sources form by addition of <1% carbonated eclogite ± sediment-derived C-O-H-Cl fluids to depleted mantle at 180–280 km (EM) or within the transition zone (PREMA).

Original language	English (US)
Pages (from-to)	3801-3839
Number of pages	39
Journal	Geochemistry, Geophysics, Geosystems
Volume	18
Issue number	11
DOIs	https://doi.org/10.1002/2016GC006743
State	Published - Nov 2017

Bibliographical note

Funding Information:
J.E.D. is grateful to the University of South Florida for granting a 1 week nano-sabbatical at the University of Oregon in March 2015 and a 2 month mini-sabbatical in March–April 2016 at the Carnegie Institution of Washington Department of Terrestrial Magnetism (DTM), where she was fortunate to serve as a Tuve Fellow. Work by R. Kingsley, J. Dixon, and T. Rau Hajewski was supported by NSF/OCE-0351149. This work brings together studies of MORB suites from both C. Langmuir and J.-G. Schilling funded over the years by NSF/OCE-9302574 (1993 to J. Dixon and C. Langmuir), NSF/OCE- 9530373 (1995 to J. Dixon and J.-G. Schilling), NSF/OCE-0351149 (2004 to J. Dixon, R. Kingsley, and J.-G. Schilling), NSFOCE-0351125 (2006 to R. Kingsley and J.-G. Schilling for the D/H and O isotopes along the Arctic ridges), and NSF/EAR-844772 (2009 to I. Bindeman for D/H analysis of Atlantic and north Pacific samples). Ideas were refined during many helpful discussions with Erik Hauri, Peter van Keken, Steve Shirey, and Rick Carlson. The first author is extremely grateful for the thoughtful and thorough review by A. Pietruszka. The manuscript also benefited from reviews by R. Stern and an anonymous reviewer. The data used are listed in Figures 2–8 are provided in Tables (1–4) and archived in IEDA:EarthChem [http://www. earthchem.org/library].

Publisher Copyright:
© 2017. American Geophysical Union. All Rights Reserved.

Keywords

mantle geochemistry
metasomatism
oceanic basalt
stable isotopes
subduction
volatiles

Publisher link

10.1002/2016GC006743

Find It

Find It at U of M Libraries

Cite this

Dixon, J. E., Bindeman, I. N., Kingsley, R. H., Simons, K. K., Le Roux, P. J., Hajewski, T. R., Swart, P., Langmuir, C. H., Ryan, J. G., Walowski, K. J., Wada, I., & Wallace, P. J. (2017). Light Stable Isotopic Compositions of Enriched Mantle Sources: Resolving the Dehydration Paradox. Geochemistry, Geophysics, Geosystems, 18(11), 3801-3839. https://doi.org/10.1002/2016GC006743

@article{5d2134ea9a624bc8987d3ae325db267e,

title = "Light Stable Isotopic Compositions of Enriched Mantle Sources: Resolving the Dehydration Paradox",

abstract = "Volatile and stable isotope data provide tests of mantle processes that give rise to mantle heterogeneity. New data on enriched mid-oceanic ridge basalts (MORB) show a diversity of enriched components. Pacific PREMA-type basalts (H2O/Ce = 215 ± 30, δDSMOW = −45 ± 5 ‰) are similar to those in the northern Atlantic (H2O/Ce = 220 ± 30; δDSMOW = −30 to −40 ‰). Basalts with EM-type signatures have regionally variable volatile compositions. Northern Atlantic EM-type basalts are wetter (H2O/Ce = 330 ± 30) and have isotopically heavier hydrogen (δDSMOW = −57 ± 5 ‰) than northern Atlantic MORB. Southern Atlantic EM-type basalts are damp (H2O/Ce = 120 ± 10) with intermediate δDSMOW (−68 ± 2 ‰), similar to δDSMOW for Pacific MORB. Northern Pacific EM-type basalts are dry (H2O/Ce = 110 ± 20) and isotopically light (δDSMOW = −94 ± 3 ‰). A multistage metasomatic and melting model accounts for the origin of the enriched components by extending the subduction factory concept down through the mantle transition zone, with slab temperature a key variable. Volatiles and their stable isotopes are decoupled from lithophile elements, reflecting primary dehydration of the slab followed by secondary rehydration, infiltration, and re-equilibration by fluids derived from dehydrating subcrustal hydrous phases (e.g., antigorite) in cooler, deeper parts of the slab. Enriched mantle sources form by addition of <1% carbonated eclogite ± sediment-derived C-O-H-Cl fluids to depleted mantle at 180–280 km (EM) or within the transition zone (PREMA).",

keywords = "mantle geochemistry, metasomatism, oceanic basalt, stable isotopes, subduction, volatiles",

author = "Dixon, {J. E.} and Bindeman, {I. N.} and Kingsley, {R. H.} and Simons, {K. K.} and {Le Roux}, {P. J.} and Hajewski, {T. R.} and P. Swart and Langmuir, {C. H.} and Ryan, {J. G.} and Walowski, {K. J.} and I. Wada and Wallace, {P. J.}",

note = "Funding Information: J.E.D. is grateful to the University of South Florida for granting a 1 week nano-sabbatical at the University of Oregon in March 2015 and a 2 month mini-sabbatical in March–April 2016 at the Carnegie Institution of Washington Department of Terrestrial Magnetism (DTM), where she was fortunate to serve as a Tuve Fellow. Work by R. Kingsley, J. Dixon, and T. Rau Hajewski was supported by NSF/OCE-0351149. This work brings together studies of MORB suites from both C. Langmuir and J.-G. Schilling funded over the years by NSF/OCE-9302574 (1993 to J. Dixon and C. Langmuir), NSF/OCE- 9530373 (1995 to J. Dixon and J.-G. Schilling), NSF/OCE-0351149 (2004 to J. Dixon, R. Kingsley, and J.-G. Schilling), NSFOCE-0351125 (2006 to R. Kingsley and J.-G. Schilling for the D/H and O isotopes along the Arctic ridges), and NSF/EAR-844772 (2009 to I. Bindeman for D/H analysis of Atlantic and north Pacific samples). Ideas were refined during many helpful discussions with Erik Hauri, Peter van Keken, Steve Shirey, and Rick Carlson. The first author is extremely grateful for the thoughtful and thorough review by A. Pietruszka. The manuscript also benefited from reviews by R. Stern and an anonymous reviewer. The data used are listed in Figures 2–8 are provided in Tables (1–4) and archived in IEDA:EarthChem [http://www. earthchem.org/library]. Publisher Copyright: {\textcopyright} 2017. American Geophysical Union. All Rights Reserved.",

year = "2017",

month = nov,

doi = "10.1002/2016GC006743",

language = "English (US)",

volume = "18",

pages = "3801--3839",

journal = "Geochemistry, Geophysics, Geosystems",

issn = "1525-2027",

publisher = "American Geophysical Union",

number = "11",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Light Stable Isotopic Compositions of Enriched Mantle Sources

T2 - Resolving the Dehydration Paradox

AU - Dixon, J. E.

AU - Bindeman, I. N.

AU - Kingsley, R. H.

AU - Simons, K. K.

AU - Le Roux, P. J.

AU - Hajewski, T. R.

AU - Swart, P.

AU - Langmuir, C. H.

AU - Ryan, J. G.

AU - Walowski, K. J.

AU - Wada, I.

AU - Wallace, P. J.

N1 - Funding Information: J.E.D. is grateful to the University of South Florida for granting a 1 week nano-sabbatical at the University of Oregon in March 2015 and a 2 month mini-sabbatical in March–April 2016 at the Carnegie Institution of Washington Department of Terrestrial Magnetism (DTM), where she was fortunate to serve as a Tuve Fellow. Work by R. Kingsley, J. Dixon, and T. Rau Hajewski was supported by NSF/OCE-0351149. This work brings together studies of MORB suites from both C. Langmuir and J.-G. Schilling funded over the years by NSF/OCE-9302574 (1993 to J. Dixon and C. Langmuir), NSF/OCE- 9530373 (1995 to J. Dixon and J.-G. Schilling), NSF/OCE-0351149 (2004 to J. Dixon, R. Kingsley, and J.-G. Schilling), NSFOCE-0351125 (2006 to R. Kingsley and J.-G. Schilling for the D/H and O isotopes along the Arctic ridges), and NSF/EAR-844772 (2009 to I. Bindeman for D/H analysis of Atlantic and north Pacific samples). Ideas were refined during many helpful discussions with Erik Hauri, Peter van Keken, Steve Shirey, and Rick Carlson. The first author is extremely grateful for the thoughtful and thorough review by A. Pietruszka. The manuscript also benefited from reviews by R. Stern and an anonymous reviewer. The data used are listed in Figures 2–8 are provided in Tables (1–4) and archived in IEDA:EarthChem [http://www. earthchem.org/library]. Publisher Copyright: © 2017. American Geophysical Union. All Rights Reserved.

PY - 2017/11

Y1 - 2017/11

N2 - Volatile and stable isotope data provide tests of mantle processes that give rise to mantle heterogeneity. New data on enriched mid-oceanic ridge basalts (MORB) show a diversity of enriched components. Pacific PREMA-type basalts (H2O/Ce = 215 ± 30, δDSMOW = −45 ± 5 ‰) are similar to those in the northern Atlantic (H2O/Ce = 220 ± 30; δDSMOW = −30 to −40 ‰). Basalts with EM-type signatures have regionally variable volatile compositions. Northern Atlantic EM-type basalts are wetter (H2O/Ce = 330 ± 30) and have isotopically heavier hydrogen (δDSMOW = −57 ± 5 ‰) than northern Atlantic MORB. Southern Atlantic EM-type basalts are damp (H2O/Ce = 120 ± 10) with intermediate δDSMOW (−68 ± 2 ‰), similar to δDSMOW for Pacific MORB. Northern Pacific EM-type basalts are dry (H2O/Ce = 110 ± 20) and isotopically light (δDSMOW = −94 ± 3 ‰). A multistage metasomatic and melting model accounts for the origin of the enriched components by extending the subduction factory concept down through the mantle transition zone, with slab temperature a key variable. Volatiles and their stable isotopes are decoupled from lithophile elements, reflecting primary dehydration of the slab followed by secondary rehydration, infiltration, and re-equilibration by fluids derived from dehydrating subcrustal hydrous phases (e.g., antigorite) in cooler, deeper parts of the slab. Enriched mantle sources form by addition of <1% carbonated eclogite ± sediment-derived C-O-H-Cl fluids to depleted mantle at 180–280 km (EM) or within the transition zone (PREMA).

AB - Volatile and stable isotope data provide tests of mantle processes that give rise to mantle heterogeneity. New data on enriched mid-oceanic ridge basalts (MORB) show a diversity of enriched components. Pacific PREMA-type basalts (H2O/Ce = 215 ± 30, δDSMOW = −45 ± 5 ‰) are similar to those in the northern Atlantic (H2O/Ce = 220 ± 30; δDSMOW = −30 to −40 ‰). Basalts with EM-type signatures have regionally variable volatile compositions. Northern Atlantic EM-type basalts are wetter (H2O/Ce = 330 ± 30) and have isotopically heavier hydrogen (δDSMOW = −57 ± 5 ‰) than northern Atlantic MORB. Southern Atlantic EM-type basalts are damp (H2O/Ce = 120 ± 10) with intermediate δDSMOW (−68 ± 2 ‰), similar to δDSMOW for Pacific MORB. Northern Pacific EM-type basalts are dry (H2O/Ce = 110 ± 20) and isotopically light (δDSMOW = −94 ± 3 ‰). A multistage metasomatic and melting model accounts for the origin of the enriched components by extending the subduction factory concept down through the mantle transition zone, with slab temperature a key variable. Volatiles and their stable isotopes are decoupled from lithophile elements, reflecting primary dehydration of the slab followed by secondary rehydration, infiltration, and re-equilibration by fluids derived from dehydrating subcrustal hydrous phases (e.g., antigorite) in cooler, deeper parts of the slab. Enriched mantle sources form by addition of <1% carbonated eclogite ± sediment-derived C-O-H-Cl fluids to depleted mantle at 180–280 km (EM) or within the transition zone (PREMA).

KW - mantle geochemistry

KW - metasomatism

KW - oceanic basalt

KW - stable isotopes

KW - subduction

KW - volatiles

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85038350644&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85038350644&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1002/2016GC006743

DO - 10.1002/2016GC006743

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:85038350644

SN - 1525-2027

VL - 18

SP - 3801

EP - 3839

JO - Geochemistry, Geophysics, Geosystems

JF - Geochemistry, Geophysics, Geosystems

IS - 11

ER -

Light Stable Isotopic Compositions of Enriched Mantle Sources: Resolving the Dehydration Paradox

Abstract

Bibliographical note

Keywords

Publisher link

Find It

Other files and links

Fingerprint

Cite this