Learning to play the Violin: Motor control by freezing, not freeing degrees of freedom

Jürgen Konczak, Heidi Vander Velden, Lukas Jaeger

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

45 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Playing a violin requires precise patterns of limb coordination that are acquired over years of practice. In the present study, the authors investigated how motion at proximal arm joints influenced the precision of bow movements in novice learners and experts. The authors evaluated the performances of 11 children (4-12 years old), 3 beginning-to-advanced level adult players, and 2 adult concert violinists, using a musical work that all had mastered as their first violin piece. The authors found that learning to play the violin was not associated with a release or freeing of joint degrees of freedom. Instead, learning was characterized by an experience-dependent suppression of sagittal shoulder motion, as documented by an observed reduction in joint angular amplitude. This reduction in the amplitude of shoulder flexion-extension correlated highly with a decrease of bow-movement variability. The remaining mechanical degrees of freedom at the elbow and shoulder showed patterns of neither suppression nor freeing. Only violinists with more than 700 practice hr achieved sagittal shoulder range of motion comparable to experts. The findings imply that restricting joint amplitude at selected joint degrees of freedom, while leaving other degrees of freedom unconstrained, constitutes an appropriate strategy for learning complex, high-precision motor patterns in children and adults. The findings also highlight that mastering even seemingly simple bowing movements constitutes a prolonged learning process.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)243-252
Number of pages10
JournalJournal of Motor Behavior
Volume41
Issue number3
DOIs
StatePublished - May 1 2009

Fingerprint

Freezing
Learning
Joints
Elbow
Articular Range of Motion
Arm
Extremities

Keywords

  • Bernstein
  • Development
  • Expert
  • Motor control
  • Motor learning
  • Music

Cite this

Learning to play the Violin : Motor control by freezing, not freeing degrees of freedom. / Konczak, Jürgen; Vander Velden, Heidi; Jaeger, Lukas.

In: Journal of Motor Behavior, Vol. 41, No. 3, 01.05.2009, p. 243-252.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Konczak, Jürgen ; Vander Velden, Heidi ; Jaeger, Lukas. / Learning to play the Violin : Motor control by freezing, not freeing degrees of freedom. In: Journal of Motor Behavior. 2009 ; Vol. 41, No. 3. pp. 243-252.
@article{2a7fe555ea524b9ba217002bfb6f6eea,
title = "Learning to play the Violin: Motor control by freezing, not freeing degrees of freedom",
abstract = "Playing a violin requires precise patterns of limb coordination that are acquired over years of practice. In the present study, the authors investigated how motion at proximal arm joints influenced the precision of bow movements in novice learners and experts. The authors evaluated the performances of 11 children (4-12 years old), 3 beginning-to-advanced level adult players, and 2 adult concert violinists, using a musical work that all had mastered as their first violin piece. The authors found that learning to play the violin was not associated with a release or freeing of joint degrees of freedom. Instead, learning was characterized by an experience-dependent suppression of sagittal shoulder motion, as documented by an observed reduction in joint angular amplitude. This reduction in the amplitude of shoulder flexion-extension correlated highly with a decrease of bow-movement variability. The remaining mechanical degrees of freedom at the elbow and shoulder showed patterns of neither suppression nor freeing. Only violinists with more than 700 practice hr achieved sagittal shoulder range of motion comparable to experts. The findings imply that restricting joint amplitude at selected joint degrees of freedom, while leaving other degrees of freedom unconstrained, constitutes an appropriate strategy for learning complex, high-precision motor patterns in children and adults. The findings also highlight that mastering even seemingly simple bowing movements constitutes a prolonged learning process.",
keywords = "Bernstein, Development, Expert, Motor control, Motor learning, Music",
author = "J{\"u}rgen Konczak and {Vander Velden}, Heidi and Lukas Jaeger",
year = "2009",
month = "5",
day = "1",
doi = "10.3200/JMBR.41.3.243-252",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "41",
pages = "243--252",
journal = "Journal of Motor Behavior",
issn = "0022-2895",
publisher = "Routledge",
number = "3",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Learning to play the Violin

T2 - Motor control by freezing, not freeing degrees of freedom

AU - Konczak, Jürgen

AU - Vander Velden, Heidi

AU - Jaeger, Lukas

PY - 2009/5/1

Y1 - 2009/5/1

N2 - Playing a violin requires precise patterns of limb coordination that are acquired over years of practice. In the present study, the authors investigated how motion at proximal arm joints influenced the precision of bow movements in novice learners and experts. The authors evaluated the performances of 11 children (4-12 years old), 3 beginning-to-advanced level adult players, and 2 adult concert violinists, using a musical work that all had mastered as their first violin piece. The authors found that learning to play the violin was not associated with a release or freeing of joint degrees of freedom. Instead, learning was characterized by an experience-dependent suppression of sagittal shoulder motion, as documented by an observed reduction in joint angular amplitude. This reduction in the amplitude of shoulder flexion-extension correlated highly with a decrease of bow-movement variability. The remaining mechanical degrees of freedom at the elbow and shoulder showed patterns of neither suppression nor freeing. Only violinists with more than 700 practice hr achieved sagittal shoulder range of motion comparable to experts. The findings imply that restricting joint amplitude at selected joint degrees of freedom, while leaving other degrees of freedom unconstrained, constitutes an appropriate strategy for learning complex, high-precision motor patterns in children and adults. The findings also highlight that mastering even seemingly simple bowing movements constitutes a prolonged learning process.

AB - Playing a violin requires precise patterns of limb coordination that are acquired over years of practice. In the present study, the authors investigated how motion at proximal arm joints influenced the precision of bow movements in novice learners and experts. The authors evaluated the performances of 11 children (4-12 years old), 3 beginning-to-advanced level adult players, and 2 adult concert violinists, using a musical work that all had mastered as their first violin piece. The authors found that learning to play the violin was not associated with a release or freeing of joint degrees of freedom. Instead, learning was characterized by an experience-dependent suppression of sagittal shoulder motion, as documented by an observed reduction in joint angular amplitude. This reduction in the amplitude of shoulder flexion-extension correlated highly with a decrease of bow-movement variability. The remaining mechanical degrees of freedom at the elbow and shoulder showed patterns of neither suppression nor freeing. Only violinists with more than 700 practice hr achieved sagittal shoulder range of motion comparable to experts. The findings imply that restricting joint amplitude at selected joint degrees of freedom, while leaving other degrees of freedom unconstrained, constitutes an appropriate strategy for learning complex, high-precision motor patterns in children and adults. The findings also highlight that mastering even seemingly simple bowing movements constitutes a prolonged learning process.

KW - Bernstein

KW - Development

KW - Expert

KW - Motor control

KW - Motor learning

KW - Music

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=66749094707&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=66749094707&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.3200/JMBR.41.3.243-252

DO - 10.3200/JMBR.41.3.243-252

M3 - Article

C2 - 19366657

AN - SCOPUS:66749094707

VL - 41

SP - 243

EP - 252

JO - Journal of Motor Behavior

JF - Journal of Motor Behavior

SN - 0022-2895

IS - 3

ER -