Isotropic failure criteria are not appropriate for anisotropic fibrous biological tissues

Christopher E. Korenczuk, Lauren E. Votava, Rohit Y. Dhume, Shannen B. Kizilski, George E. Brown, Rahul Narain, Victor H Barocas

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

2 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

The von Mises (VM) stress is a common stress measure for finite element models of tissue mechanics. The VM failure criterion, however, is inherently isotropic, and therefore may yield incorrect results for anisotropic tissues, and the relevance of the VM stress to anisotropic materials is not clear. We explored the application of a well-studied anisotropic failure criterion, the Tsai-Hill (TH) theory, to the mechanically anisotropic porcine aorta. Uniaxial dogbones were cut at different angles and stretched to failure. The tissue was anisotropic, with the circumferential failure stress nearly twice the axial (2.67±0.67 MPa compared to 1.46±0.59 MPa). The VM failure criterion did not capture the anisotropic tissue response, but the TH criterion fit the data well (R2=0.986). Shear lap samples were also tested to study the efficacy of each criterion in predicting tissue failure. Two-dimensional failure propagation simulations showed that the VM failure criterion did not capture the failure type, location, or propagation direction nearly as well as the TH criterion. Over the range of loading conditions and tissue geometries studied, we found that problematic results that arise when applying the VM failure criterion to an anisotropic tissue. In contrast, the TH failure criterion, though simplistic and clearly unable to capture all aspects of tissue failure, performed much better. Ultimately, isotropic failure criteria are not appropriate for anisotropic tissues, and the use of the VM stress as a metric of mechanical state should be reconsidered when dealing with anisotropic tissues.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Article number4036316
JournalJournal of Biomechanical Engineering
Volume139
Issue number7
DOIs
StatePublished - Jul 1 2017

Fingerprint

Tissue
Mechanics
Aorta
Swine
Geometry

Keywords

  • Anisotropy
  • Biomechanics
  • Failure criteria
  • Von Mises stress

Cite this

Isotropic failure criteria are not appropriate for anisotropic fibrous biological tissues. / Korenczuk, Christopher E.; Votava, Lauren E.; Dhume, Rohit Y.; Kizilski, Shannen B.; Brown, George E.; Narain, Rahul; Barocas, Victor H.

In: Journal of Biomechanical Engineering, Vol. 139, No. 7, 4036316, 01.07.2017.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Korenczuk, Christopher E. ; Votava, Lauren E. ; Dhume, Rohit Y. ; Kizilski, Shannen B. ; Brown, George E. ; Narain, Rahul ; Barocas, Victor H. / Isotropic failure criteria are not appropriate for anisotropic fibrous biological tissues. In: Journal of Biomechanical Engineering. 2017 ; Vol. 139, No. 7.
@article{5eef95957d574362b5ffcba637fb9350,
title = "Isotropic failure criteria are not appropriate for anisotropic fibrous biological tissues",
abstract = "The von Mises (VM) stress is a common stress measure for finite element models of tissue mechanics. The VM failure criterion, however, is inherently isotropic, and therefore may yield incorrect results for anisotropic tissues, and the relevance of the VM stress to anisotropic materials is not clear. We explored the application of a well-studied anisotropic failure criterion, the Tsai-Hill (TH) theory, to the mechanically anisotropic porcine aorta. Uniaxial dogbones were cut at different angles and stretched to failure. The tissue was anisotropic, with the circumferential failure stress nearly twice the axial (2.67±0.67 MPa compared to 1.46±0.59 MPa). The VM failure criterion did not capture the anisotropic tissue response, but the TH criterion fit the data well (R2=0.986). Shear lap samples were also tested to study the efficacy of each criterion in predicting tissue failure. Two-dimensional failure propagation simulations showed that the VM failure criterion did not capture the failure type, location, or propagation direction nearly as well as the TH criterion. Over the range of loading conditions and tissue geometries studied, we found that problematic results that arise when applying the VM failure criterion to an anisotropic tissue. In contrast, the TH failure criterion, though simplistic and clearly unable to capture all aspects of tissue failure, performed much better. Ultimately, isotropic failure criteria are not appropriate for anisotropic tissues, and the use of the VM stress as a metric of mechanical state should be reconsidered when dealing with anisotropic tissues.",
keywords = "Anisotropy, Biomechanics, Failure criteria, Von Mises stress",
author = "Korenczuk, {Christopher E.} and Votava, {Lauren E.} and Dhume, {Rohit Y.} and Kizilski, {Shannen B.} and Brown, {George E.} and Rahul Narain and Barocas, {Victor H}",
year = "2017",
month = "7",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1115/1.4036316",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "139",
journal = "Journal of Biomechanical Engineering",
issn = "0148-0731",
publisher = "American Society of Mechanical Engineers(ASME)",
number = "7",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Isotropic failure criteria are not appropriate for anisotropic fibrous biological tissues

AU - Korenczuk, Christopher E.

AU - Votava, Lauren E.

AU - Dhume, Rohit Y.

AU - Kizilski, Shannen B.

AU - Brown, George E.

AU - Narain, Rahul

AU - Barocas, Victor H

PY - 2017/7/1

Y1 - 2017/7/1

N2 - The von Mises (VM) stress is a common stress measure for finite element models of tissue mechanics. The VM failure criterion, however, is inherently isotropic, and therefore may yield incorrect results for anisotropic tissues, and the relevance of the VM stress to anisotropic materials is not clear. We explored the application of a well-studied anisotropic failure criterion, the Tsai-Hill (TH) theory, to the mechanically anisotropic porcine aorta. Uniaxial dogbones were cut at different angles and stretched to failure. The tissue was anisotropic, with the circumferential failure stress nearly twice the axial (2.67±0.67 MPa compared to 1.46±0.59 MPa). The VM failure criterion did not capture the anisotropic tissue response, but the TH criterion fit the data well (R2=0.986). Shear lap samples were also tested to study the efficacy of each criterion in predicting tissue failure. Two-dimensional failure propagation simulations showed that the VM failure criterion did not capture the failure type, location, or propagation direction nearly as well as the TH criterion. Over the range of loading conditions and tissue geometries studied, we found that problematic results that arise when applying the VM failure criterion to an anisotropic tissue. In contrast, the TH failure criterion, though simplistic and clearly unable to capture all aspects of tissue failure, performed much better. Ultimately, isotropic failure criteria are not appropriate for anisotropic tissues, and the use of the VM stress as a metric of mechanical state should be reconsidered when dealing with anisotropic tissues.

AB - The von Mises (VM) stress is a common stress measure for finite element models of tissue mechanics. The VM failure criterion, however, is inherently isotropic, and therefore may yield incorrect results for anisotropic tissues, and the relevance of the VM stress to anisotropic materials is not clear. We explored the application of a well-studied anisotropic failure criterion, the Tsai-Hill (TH) theory, to the mechanically anisotropic porcine aorta. Uniaxial dogbones were cut at different angles and stretched to failure. The tissue was anisotropic, with the circumferential failure stress nearly twice the axial (2.67±0.67 MPa compared to 1.46±0.59 MPa). The VM failure criterion did not capture the anisotropic tissue response, but the TH criterion fit the data well (R2=0.986). Shear lap samples were also tested to study the efficacy of each criterion in predicting tissue failure. Two-dimensional failure propagation simulations showed that the VM failure criterion did not capture the failure type, location, or propagation direction nearly as well as the TH criterion. Over the range of loading conditions and tissue geometries studied, we found that problematic results that arise when applying the VM failure criterion to an anisotropic tissue. In contrast, the TH failure criterion, though simplistic and clearly unable to capture all aspects of tissue failure, performed much better. Ultimately, isotropic failure criteria are not appropriate for anisotropic tissues, and the use of the VM stress as a metric of mechanical state should be reconsidered when dealing with anisotropic tissues.

KW - Anisotropy

KW - Biomechanics

KW - Failure criteria

KW - Von Mises stress

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85021729055&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85021729055&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1115/1.4036316

DO - 10.1115/1.4036316

M3 - Article

VL - 139

JO - Journal of Biomechanical Engineering

JF - Journal of Biomechanical Engineering

SN - 0148-0731

IS - 7

M1 - 4036316

ER -