Intermediate-term prospective results of radiofrequency-assisted laparoscopic partial nephrectomy: A non-ischaemic coagulative technique

OBJECTIVE: To report the first intermediate-term oncological outcomes of laparoscopic radiofrequency coagulation followed by laparoscopic partial nephrectomy (RF-LPN) to treat small renal masses, as LPN is limited by the technical difficulty of efficient tumour resection and parenchymal repair during warm ischaemia of the kidney. PATIENTS AND METHODS: A prospective database was searched to identify patients treated with RF-LPN; in each case the tumour was first RF coagulated with a margin of normal parenchyma, and then excised. Only fibrin glue was applied to the haemostatic resection site to prevent urinary leaks. In all, 32 tumours were treated with this approach, and a radiographic follow-up was completed yearly. RESULTS: All PNs were accomplished with no hilar clamping, with a mean blood loss of 80 mL; 72% of masses were renal cell carcinoma. There was a positive margin in four masses (13%); 29 tumours (mean size 1.9 cm) were eligible for analysis of oncological outcomes, with a mean follow-up of 31 months. There were no tumour recurrences at the last follow-up, giving a cancer-specific survival rate of 100%. CONCLUSIONS: RF-LPN with no hilar clamping simplifies the surgical technique and appears to have excellent cancer control in the intermediate term. In the few patients with a positive surgical margin, it is possible that coagulation beyond the tumour margin kills any residual microscopic tumour, minimizing or obviating the risk of tumour recurrence. Nevertheless, vigilance during tumour excision and margin identification is mandatory.