Eutrophication can initiate sudden ecosystem state change either by slowly pushing lakes toward a catastrophic tipping point beyond which self-reinforcing mechanisms establish an alternate stable state, or through rapid but persistent changes in external forcing mechanisms. In principle, these processes can be distinguished by determining whether historical changes in focal parameters (phytoplankton) exhibit transient (rising then declining) or continuously-elevated variability characteristic of alternate stable states or a “paradox of enrichment,” respectively. We tested this hypothesis in the south basin of Lake Winnipeg, Canada, a site with intense blooms of N2-fixing cyanobacteria since 1990, but for which little is known of earlier limnological conditions, causes of eutrophication, or whether modern conditions represent a alternate stable state. Paleolimnological analysis revealed that the basin was naturally mesotrophic (∼15–20 μg P L−1) with diazotrophic cyanobacteria, productive diatoms, and phosphorus-rich sediments. Eutrophication accelerated during ca.1900–ca.1990, when sedimentary nitrogen, phosphorus and carbon contents increased 10–50%, δ15N enriched 3–4‰, and concentrations of many fossil pigments increased 300–500%. Nearly 75% of 20th century variability was explained by concomitant increases in production of livestock and crops, but not by climate. After ca.1990, the basin exhibited a rapid threefold increase in akinetes from Aphanizomenon and Anabaena spp. and 50% declines in pigments from chlorophytes and cyanobacteria because of sudden socio-economic reorganization of agriculture. Phytoplankton variability quantified using Gaussian generalized additive models increased continuously since the onset of agriculture for bloom-forming taxa, did not decline after state change, and suggested that recovery should not be affected by stable-state hysteresis.
Bibliographical noteFunding Information:
We thank Jill Coleman for sedimentary phosphorus determinations, Zoraida Qui?ones-Rivera for pigment analyses, Derek Donald and Martin Callaghan for core collection, and Manitoba Conservation and Water Stewardship for maps and limnological data. We thank Alex Salki and the Lake Winnipeg Research Consortium for facilitating shiptime on the MV Namao. This project was supported by Manitoba Conservation and Water Stewardship, Natural Science and Engineering Research Council of Canada (NSERC), the Canada Research Chair program, Canada Foundation for Innovation, Fulbright Canada, the Province of Saskatchewan, and the University of Regina. This manuscript was improved by reviews from D. A. Seekell, D. E. Schindler, R. J. Vogt, D.W. Schindler, K. Finlay, D. Williamson, N. Armstrong, B. R. Parker, G.W. Kling, J. A. Downing, and four anonymous reviewers.
© 2016 The Authors Limnology and Oceanography published by Wiley Periodicals, Inc. on behalf of Association for the Sciences of Limnology and Oceanography