Iman & Ihsan, application in physician training and the therapeutic relationship

Zehraa Cheaib, Arif Somani

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

The journey from illness to health may be fraught with unfavorable outcomes, inadvertent errors, or even medical malpractice. Indeed, alleged medical negligence or malpractice is emblematic of the underlying dissonance in what should otherwise be an ideal therapeutic relationship between physicians and patients. The increasing incidence of alleged medical negligence in the West and in the Muslim world has led physicians to fear the threat of litigation. Consequently, this results in defensive medicine, avoiding higher risk medical and surgical specialties or procedures, and potentially adversarial patient-physician interactions. Medical schools have adopted white coat ceremonies as a symbolic attempt to inculcate students in the healing tradition and; along with the pledging of the Hippocratic Oath, to imbue them with a sense of compassion and duty towards the ill. Such endeavors should serve to motivate trainees and physicians to respond to suffering with continued empathy and effort rather than with suspicion and fear of an unfavorable outcome or alleged negligence. Objective: The purpose of this paper is to offer a novel, complimentary approach to the white coat ceremony and the pledging of the Hippocratic Oath, by discerning the Islamic principles of Iman (faith) and Ihsan (a call to virtue) to define an appropriate healing relationship between physicians and patients. In order to introduce students to this tradition of healing, this alternative approach may be introduced, taught, and modeled for physicians-in-training in their actual clinical practice. Philosophical Perspective: Since inception of the white coat ceremony in 1993, the Hippocratic perspective has been applied to inculcate a sense of compassion and duty to the ill. Along with recognition of the Human Condition or Fitra; the concept of Iman and Ihsan within the Muslim world should be applied by physicians-in-training to define their duty and their approach to future patients, themselves and their Creator. Such an approach demands a higher level calling than that outlined by the expected standards of Islamic law or Shari’a. Conclusion: Instilling Iman and Ihsan principles as an embedded component of medical treatment potentially should curtail medical malpractice exposure, simplify due process, and improve patient physician healing relationships.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)471-486
Number of pages16
JournalMedicine and Law
Volume34
Issue number3
StatePublished - Jan 1 2015

Fingerprint

Malpractice
physician
Physicians
Physician-Patient Relations
Hippocratic Oath
Islam
oath
Fear
Defensive Medicine
Therapeutics
Muslim
Surgical Specialties
Students
Civil Rights
sharia
anxiety
physician-patient relationship
Jurisprudence
Medical Schools
physician's care

Keywords

  • Bioethics
  • Fitra
  • Hippocratic oath
  • Ihsan
  • Iman
  • Litigation
  • Medical errors
  • Medical malpractice
  • Muslim virtue
  • White coat ceremony

Cite this

Iman & Ihsan, application in physician training and the therapeutic relationship. / Cheaib, Zehraa; Somani, Arif.

In: Medicine and Law, Vol. 34, No. 3, 01.01.2015, p. 471-486.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{e463db6f7d0f4889a1b14315546146cd,
title = "Iman & Ihsan, application in physician training and the therapeutic relationship",
abstract = "The journey from illness to health may be fraught with unfavorable outcomes, inadvertent errors, or even medical malpractice. Indeed, alleged medical negligence or malpractice is emblematic of the underlying dissonance in what should otherwise be an ideal therapeutic relationship between physicians and patients. The increasing incidence of alleged medical negligence in the West and in the Muslim world has led physicians to fear the threat of litigation. Consequently, this results in defensive medicine, avoiding higher risk medical and surgical specialties or procedures, and potentially adversarial patient-physician interactions. Medical schools have adopted white coat ceremonies as a symbolic attempt to inculcate students in the healing tradition and; along with the pledging of the Hippocratic Oath, to imbue them with a sense of compassion and duty towards the ill. Such endeavors should serve to motivate trainees and physicians to respond to suffering with continued empathy and effort rather than with suspicion and fear of an unfavorable outcome or alleged negligence. Objective: The purpose of this paper is to offer a novel, complimentary approach to the white coat ceremony and the pledging of the Hippocratic Oath, by discerning the Islamic principles of Iman (faith) and Ihsan (a call to virtue) to define an appropriate healing relationship between physicians and patients. In order to introduce students to this tradition of healing, this alternative approach may be introduced, taught, and modeled for physicians-in-training in their actual clinical practice. Philosophical Perspective: Since inception of the white coat ceremony in 1993, the Hippocratic perspective has been applied to inculcate a sense of compassion and duty to the ill. Along with recognition of the Human Condition or Fitra; the concept of Iman and Ihsan within the Muslim world should be applied by physicians-in-training to define their duty and their approach to future patients, themselves and their Creator. Such an approach demands a higher level calling than that outlined by the expected standards of Islamic law or Shari’a. Conclusion: Instilling Iman and Ihsan principles as an embedded component of medical treatment potentially should curtail medical malpractice exposure, simplify due process, and improve patient physician healing relationships.",
keywords = "Bioethics, Fitra, Hippocratic oath, Ihsan, Iman, Litigation, Medical errors, Medical malpractice, Muslim virtue, White coat ceremony",
author = "Zehraa Cheaib and Arif Somani",
year = "2015",
month = "1",
day = "1",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "34",
pages = "471--486",
journal = "Medicine and Law",
issn = "0723-1393",
publisher = "Yozmot Ltd",
number = "3",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Iman & Ihsan, application in physician training and the therapeutic relationship

AU - Cheaib, Zehraa

AU - Somani, Arif

PY - 2015/1/1

Y1 - 2015/1/1

N2 - The journey from illness to health may be fraught with unfavorable outcomes, inadvertent errors, or even medical malpractice. Indeed, alleged medical negligence or malpractice is emblematic of the underlying dissonance in what should otherwise be an ideal therapeutic relationship between physicians and patients. The increasing incidence of alleged medical negligence in the West and in the Muslim world has led physicians to fear the threat of litigation. Consequently, this results in defensive medicine, avoiding higher risk medical and surgical specialties or procedures, and potentially adversarial patient-physician interactions. Medical schools have adopted white coat ceremonies as a symbolic attempt to inculcate students in the healing tradition and; along with the pledging of the Hippocratic Oath, to imbue them with a sense of compassion and duty towards the ill. Such endeavors should serve to motivate trainees and physicians to respond to suffering with continued empathy and effort rather than with suspicion and fear of an unfavorable outcome or alleged negligence. Objective: The purpose of this paper is to offer a novel, complimentary approach to the white coat ceremony and the pledging of the Hippocratic Oath, by discerning the Islamic principles of Iman (faith) and Ihsan (a call to virtue) to define an appropriate healing relationship between physicians and patients. In order to introduce students to this tradition of healing, this alternative approach may be introduced, taught, and modeled for physicians-in-training in their actual clinical practice. Philosophical Perspective: Since inception of the white coat ceremony in 1993, the Hippocratic perspective has been applied to inculcate a sense of compassion and duty to the ill. Along with recognition of the Human Condition or Fitra; the concept of Iman and Ihsan within the Muslim world should be applied by physicians-in-training to define their duty and their approach to future patients, themselves and their Creator. Such an approach demands a higher level calling than that outlined by the expected standards of Islamic law or Shari’a. Conclusion: Instilling Iman and Ihsan principles as an embedded component of medical treatment potentially should curtail medical malpractice exposure, simplify due process, and improve patient physician healing relationships.

AB - The journey from illness to health may be fraught with unfavorable outcomes, inadvertent errors, or even medical malpractice. Indeed, alleged medical negligence or malpractice is emblematic of the underlying dissonance in what should otherwise be an ideal therapeutic relationship between physicians and patients. The increasing incidence of alleged medical negligence in the West and in the Muslim world has led physicians to fear the threat of litigation. Consequently, this results in defensive medicine, avoiding higher risk medical and surgical specialties or procedures, and potentially adversarial patient-physician interactions. Medical schools have adopted white coat ceremonies as a symbolic attempt to inculcate students in the healing tradition and; along with the pledging of the Hippocratic Oath, to imbue them with a sense of compassion and duty towards the ill. Such endeavors should serve to motivate trainees and physicians to respond to suffering with continued empathy and effort rather than with suspicion and fear of an unfavorable outcome or alleged negligence. Objective: The purpose of this paper is to offer a novel, complimentary approach to the white coat ceremony and the pledging of the Hippocratic Oath, by discerning the Islamic principles of Iman (faith) and Ihsan (a call to virtue) to define an appropriate healing relationship between physicians and patients. In order to introduce students to this tradition of healing, this alternative approach may be introduced, taught, and modeled for physicians-in-training in their actual clinical practice. Philosophical Perspective: Since inception of the white coat ceremony in 1993, the Hippocratic perspective has been applied to inculcate a sense of compassion and duty to the ill. Along with recognition of the Human Condition or Fitra; the concept of Iman and Ihsan within the Muslim world should be applied by physicians-in-training to define their duty and their approach to future patients, themselves and their Creator. Such an approach demands a higher level calling than that outlined by the expected standards of Islamic law or Shari’a. Conclusion: Instilling Iman and Ihsan principles as an embedded component of medical treatment potentially should curtail medical malpractice exposure, simplify due process, and improve patient physician healing relationships.

KW - Bioethics

KW - Fitra

KW - Hippocratic oath

KW - Ihsan

KW - Iman

KW - Litigation

KW - Medical errors

KW - Medical malpractice

KW - Muslim virtue

KW - White coat ceremony

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85000716770&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85000716770&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

VL - 34

SP - 471

EP - 486

JO - Medicine and Law

JF - Medicine and Law

SN - 0723-1393

IS - 3

ER -