GRAY TONE VERSUS LINE PLOTTER AREA SYMBOLS

A matching experiment

Terry A. Slocum, Robert B. McMaster

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Gray tones and line plotter shades are two common area symbols used to display quantitative data on maps. Since these two symbols are visually quite different from one another, the question arises as to whether or not the overall spatial message communicated by maps using these symbols would be identical for a particular data set. As a preliminary to answering this broader question, an experiment was performed in which subjects matched individual line plotter shades with gray tones. The purpose of this experiment was twofold: 1) determine the general relation between the two symbol types, and 2) determine the ease with which line plotter symbols could serve as substitutes for gray tones. The results revealed first that the general relation is essentially linear; a gray tone of a given percent area inked can be represented by a line plotter shade of about the same percent area inked. As such, the results support those obtained in previous gray scale studies. Secondly, both the actual response data and comments provided by subjects indicate that line plotter symbols are difficult to match with gray tones. This difficulty may portend differences for the overall spatial message communicated by these two symbol types.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)151-164
Number of pages14
JournalAmerican Cartographer
Volume13
Issue number2
DOIs
StatePublished - Apr 1986

Fingerprint

symbol
experiment
Experiments
Symbol
Experiment

Keywords

  • Area symbol maps
  • Gray curves
  • Gray tones
  • Line plotter shadings
  • Symbolization

Cite this

GRAY TONE VERSUS LINE PLOTTER AREA SYMBOLS : A matching experiment. / Slocum, Terry A.; McMaster, Robert B.

In: American Cartographer, Vol. 13, No. 2, 04.1986, p. 151-164.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{028795f19f91497d9fa1ec1290e09151,
title = "GRAY TONE VERSUS LINE PLOTTER AREA SYMBOLS: A matching experiment",
abstract = "Gray tones and line plotter shades are two common area symbols used to display quantitative data on maps. Since these two symbols are visually quite different from one another, the question arises as to whether or not the overall spatial message communicated by maps using these symbols would be identical for a particular data set. As a preliminary to answering this broader question, an experiment was performed in which subjects matched individual line plotter shades with gray tones. The purpose of this experiment was twofold: 1) determine the general relation between the two symbol types, and 2) determine the ease with which line plotter symbols could serve as substitutes for gray tones. The results revealed first that the general relation is essentially linear; a gray tone of a given percent area inked can be represented by a line plotter shade of about the same percent area inked. As such, the results support those obtained in previous gray scale studies. Secondly, both the actual response data and comments provided by subjects indicate that line plotter symbols are difficult to match with gray tones. This difficulty may portend differences for the overall spatial message communicated by these two symbol types.",
keywords = "Area symbol maps, Gray curves, Gray tones, Line plotter shadings, Symbolization",
author = "Slocum, {Terry A.} and McMaster, {Robert B.}",
year = "1986",
month = "4",
doi = "10.1559/152304086783900086",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "13",
pages = "151--164",
journal = "Cartography and Geographic Information Science",
issn = "1523-0406",
publisher = "American Congress on Surveying and Mapping",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - GRAY TONE VERSUS LINE PLOTTER AREA SYMBOLS

T2 - A matching experiment

AU - Slocum, Terry A.

AU - McMaster, Robert B.

PY - 1986/4

Y1 - 1986/4

N2 - Gray tones and line plotter shades are two common area symbols used to display quantitative data on maps. Since these two symbols are visually quite different from one another, the question arises as to whether or not the overall spatial message communicated by maps using these symbols would be identical for a particular data set. As a preliminary to answering this broader question, an experiment was performed in which subjects matched individual line plotter shades with gray tones. The purpose of this experiment was twofold: 1) determine the general relation between the two symbol types, and 2) determine the ease with which line plotter symbols could serve as substitutes for gray tones. The results revealed first that the general relation is essentially linear; a gray tone of a given percent area inked can be represented by a line plotter shade of about the same percent area inked. As such, the results support those obtained in previous gray scale studies. Secondly, both the actual response data and comments provided by subjects indicate that line plotter symbols are difficult to match with gray tones. This difficulty may portend differences for the overall spatial message communicated by these two symbol types.

AB - Gray tones and line plotter shades are two common area symbols used to display quantitative data on maps. Since these two symbols are visually quite different from one another, the question arises as to whether or not the overall spatial message communicated by maps using these symbols would be identical for a particular data set. As a preliminary to answering this broader question, an experiment was performed in which subjects matched individual line plotter shades with gray tones. The purpose of this experiment was twofold: 1) determine the general relation between the two symbol types, and 2) determine the ease with which line plotter symbols could serve as substitutes for gray tones. The results revealed first that the general relation is essentially linear; a gray tone of a given percent area inked can be represented by a line plotter shade of about the same percent area inked. As such, the results support those obtained in previous gray scale studies. Secondly, both the actual response data and comments provided by subjects indicate that line plotter symbols are difficult to match with gray tones. This difficulty may portend differences for the overall spatial message communicated by these two symbol types.

KW - Area symbol maps

KW - Gray curves

KW - Gray tones

KW - Line plotter shadings

KW - Symbolization

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=0022699143&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=0022699143&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1559/152304086783900086

DO - 10.1559/152304086783900086

M3 - Article

VL - 13

SP - 151

EP - 164

JO - Cartography and Geographic Information Science

JF - Cartography and Geographic Information Science

SN - 1523-0406

IS - 2

ER -