Effect of metal specific amino acid complexes and inorganic trace minerals on vitamin stability in premixes

Gerald C Shurson, Troy M Salzer, Dean D. Koehler, Mark H. Whitney

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

12 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Stability of vitamin activity in a swine premix containing metal specific amino acid complexes, inorganic trace minerals, or no trace minerals was evaluated over a 120-day storage period. Two vitamin-trace mineral premixes containing either metal specific amino acid complexes or inorganic trace mineral sources were formulated to contain 200% of NRC (1988) sow requirements for I, Cu, Zn, Mn, Fe, and Se based on a 5. g/kg dietary inclusion rate. A separate vitamin premix containing no trace minerals served as the control. The vitamin premix and the two vitamin-trace mineral premixes were formulated to contain the same level of vitamins. Vitamin levels exceeded NRC (1988) and were chosen to represent " typical" industry levels based on an informal survey of vitamin levels in commercial premixes in the U.S.A. Premixes were stored in an environmentally controlled feed storage room and samples were collected every month to determine vitamin activity. Minimal monthly vitamin stock losses in activity (0-1%) were observed for all vitamins except cyanocobalamin (2.8%) and choline (1.3%). Pantothenate, vitamin E, riboflavin, biotin and niacin were most resistant to destruction, while menadione, retinol, vitamin B-6, and thiamine were subject to the greatest loss of activity during the 120-day storage period. Use of metal specific amino acid complexes in vitamin-trace mineral premixes significantly reduced the loss of retinol, menadione, cyanocobalamin, thiamine, folates, vitamin B-6, and choline activity (P<0.05) compared to losses of vitamin activity in premixes containing inorganic trace minerals. Activity losses in retinol, cyanocobalamin, thiamine, and choline were similar between the vitamin premix and the vitamin-complexed trace mineral premix. Biotin activity was undetectable in the vitamin-complexed trace mineral premix due to unexplained analytical interference. Each vitamin was ranked according to relative vitamin assay cost, loss in vitamin activity per month, and susceptibility to multiple stress factors. This ranking was used to identify vitamins that could represent overall vitamin activity in a premix and could be assayed at a reasonable cost for a feed manufacturing quality control program. Retinol was identified as the best indicator vitamin, followed by thiamine, menadione, and cyanocobalamin. These results suggest that vitamin stability in swine vitamin-trace mineral premixes is improved when using metal specific amino acid complexes compared to inorganic trace mineral sources. More liberal safety margins for vitamins may be needed when formulating vitamin-trace mineral premixes using inorganic sources of trace minerals.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)200-206
Number of pages7
JournalAnimal Feed Science and Technology
Volume163
Issue number2-4
DOIs
StatePublished - Feb 11 2011

Fingerprint

trace elements
vitamins
metals
amino acids
vitamin B12
thiamin
menadione
vitamin A
choline
pyridoxine
biotin
storage time
margin of safety
swine

Keywords

  • Complexes
  • Pigs
  • Premixes
  • Trace minerals
  • Vitamin stability

Cite this

Effect of metal specific amino acid complexes and inorganic trace minerals on vitamin stability in premixes. / Shurson, Gerald C; Salzer, Troy M; Koehler, Dean D.; Whitney, Mark H.

In: Animal Feed Science and Technology, Vol. 163, No. 2-4, 11.02.2011, p. 200-206.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{9a9140d7342141e68c887a51feb08edf,
title = "Effect of metal specific amino acid complexes and inorganic trace minerals on vitamin stability in premixes",
abstract = "Stability of vitamin activity in a swine premix containing metal specific amino acid complexes, inorganic trace minerals, or no trace minerals was evaluated over a 120-day storage period. Two vitamin-trace mineral premixes containing either metal specific amino acid complexes or inorganic trace mineral sources were formulated to contain 200{\%} of NRC (1988) sow requirements for I, Cu, Zn, Mn, Fe, and Se based on a 5. g/kg dietary inclusion rate. A separate vitamin premix containing no trace minerals served as the control. The vitamin premix and the two vitamin-trace mineral premixes were formulated to contain the same level of vitamins. Vitamin levels exceeded NRC (1988) and were chosen to represent {"} typical{"} industry levels based on an informal survey of vitamin levels in commercial premixes in the U.S.A. Premixes were stored in an environmentally controlled feed storage room and samples were collected every month to determine vitamin activity. Minimal monthly vitamin stock losses in activity (0-1{\%}) were observed for all vitamins except cyanocobalamin (2.8{\%}) and choline (1.3{\%}). Pantothenate, vitamin E, riboflavin, biotin and niacin were most resistant to destruction, while menadione, retinol, vitamin B-6, and thiamine were subject to the greatest loss of activity during the 120-day storage period. Use of metal specific amino acid complexes in vitamin-trace mineral premixes significantly reduced the loss of retinol, menadione, cyanocobalamin, thiamine, folates, vitamin B-6, and choline activity (P<0.05) compared to losses of vitamin activity in premixes containing inorganic trace minerals. Activity losses in retinol, cyanocobalamin, thiamine, and choline were similar between the vitamin premix and the vitamin-complexed trace mineral premix. Biotin activity was undetectable in the vitamin-complexed trace mineral premix due to unexplained analytical interference. Each vitamin was ranked according to relative vitamin assay cost, loss in vitamin activity per month, and susceptibility to multiple stress factors. This ranking was used to identify vitamins that could represent overall vitamin activity in a premix and could be assayed at a reasonable cost for a feed manufacturing quality control program. Retinol was identified as the best indicator vitamin, followed by thiamine, menadione, and cyanocobalamin. These results suggest that vitamin stability in swine vitamin-trace mineral premixes is improved when using metal specific amino acid complexes compared to inorganic trace mineral sources. More liberal safety margins for vitamins may be needed when formulating vitamin-trace mineral premixes using inorganic sources of trace minerals.",
keywords = "Complexes, Pigs, Premixes, Trace minerals, Vitamin stability",
author = "Shurson, {Gerald C} and Salzer, {Troy M} and Koehler, {Dean D.} and Whitney, {Mark H.}",
year = "2011",
month = "2",
day = "11",
doi = "10.1016/j.anifeedsci.2010.11.001",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "163",
pages = "200--206",
journal = "Animal Feed Science and Technology",
issn = "0377-8401",
publisher = "Elsevier",
number = "2-4",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Effect of metal specific amino acid complexes and inorganic trace minerals on vitamin stability in premixes

AU - Shurson, Gerald C

AU - Salzer, Troy M

AU - Koehler, Dean D.

AU - Whitney, Mark H.

PY - 2011/2/11

Y1 - 2011/2/11

N2 - Stability of vitamin activity in a swine premix containing metal specific amino acid complexes, inorganic trace minerals, or no trace minerals was evaluated over a 120-day storage period. Two vitamin-trace mineral premixes containing either metal specific amino acid complexes or inorganic trace mineral sources were formulated to contain 200% of NRC (1988) sow requirements for I, Cu, Zn, Mn, Fe, and Se based on a 5. g/kg dietary inclusion rate. A separate vitamin premix containing no trace minerals served as the control. The vitamin premix and the two vitamin-trace mineral premixes were formulated to contain the same level of vitamins. Vitamin levels exceeded NRC (1988) and were chosen to represent " typical" industry levels based on an informal survey of vitamin levels in commercial premixes in the U.S.A. Premixes were stored in an environmentally controlled feed storage room and samples were collected every month to determine vitamin activity. Minimal monthly vitamin stock losses in activity (0-1%) were observed for all vitamins except cyanocobalamin (2.8%) and choline (1.3%). Pantothenate, vitamin E, riboflavin, biotin and niacin were most resistant to destruction, while menadione, retinol, vitamin B-6, and thiamine were subject to the greatest loss of activity during the 120-day storage period. Use of metal specific amino acid complexes in vitamin-trace mineral premixes significantly reduced the loss of retinol, menadione, cyanocobalamin, thiamine, folates, vitamin B-6, and choline activity (P<0.05) compared to losses of vitamin activity in premixes containing inorganic trace minerals. Activity losses in retinol, cyanocobalamin, thiamine, and choline were similar between the vitamin premix and the vitamin-complexed trace mineral premix. Biotin activity was undetectable in the vitamin-complexed trace mineral premix due to unexplained analytical interference. Each vitamin was ranked according to relative vitamin assay cost, loss in vitamin activity per month, and susceptibility to multiple stress factors. This ranking was used to identify vitamins that could represent overall vitamin activity in a premix and could be assayed at a reasonable cost for a feed manufacturing quality control program. Retinol was identified as the best indicator vitamin, followed by thiamine, menadione, and cyanocobalamin. These results suggest that vitamin stability in swine vitamin-trace mineral premixes is improved when using metal specific amino acid complexes compared to inorganic trace mineral sources. More liberal safety margins for vitamins may be needed when formulating vitamin-trace mineral premixes using inorganic sources of trace minerals.

AB - Stability of vitamin activity in a swine premix containing metal specific amino acid complexes, inorganic trace minerals, or no trace minerals was evaluated over a 120-day storage period. Two vitamin-trace mineral premixes containing either metal specific amino acid complexes or inorganic trace mineral sources were formulated to contain 200% of NRC (1988) sow requirements for I, Cu, Zn, Mn, Fe, and Se based on a 5. g/kg dietary inclusion rate. A separate vitamin premix containing no trace minerals served as the control. The vitamin premix and the two vitamin-trace mineral premixes were formulated to contain the same level of vitamins. Vitamin levels exceeded NRC (1988) and were chosen to represent " typical" industry levels based on an informal survey of vitamin levels in commercial premixes in the U.S.A. Premixes were stored in an environmentally controlled feed storage room and samples were collected every month to determine vitamin activity. Minimal monthly vitamin stock losses in activity (0-1%) were observed for all vitamins except cyanocobalamin (2.8%) and choline (1.3%). Pantothenate, vitamin E, riboflavin, biotin and niacin were most resistant to destruction, while menadione, retinol, vitamin B-6, and thiamine were subject to the greatest loss of activity during the 120-day storage period. Use of metal specific amino acid complexes in vitamin-trace mineral premixes significantly reduced the loss of retinol, menadione, cyanocobalamin, thiamine, folates, vitamin B-6, and choline activity (P<0.05) compared to losses of vitamin activity in premixes containing inorganic trace minerals. Activity losses in retinol, cyanocobalamin, thiamine, and choline were similar between the vitamin premix and the vitamin-complexed trace mineral premix. Biotin activity was undetectable in the vitamin-complexed trace mineral premix due to unexplained analytical interference. Each vitamin was ranked according to relative vitamin assay cost, loss in vitamin activity per month, and susceptibility to multiple stress factors. This ranking was used to identify vitamins that could represent overall vitamin activity in a premix and could be assayed at a reasonable cost for a feed manufacturing quality control program. Retinol was identified as the best indicator vitamin, followed by thiamine, menadione, and cyanocobalamin. These results suggest that vitamin stability in swine vitamin-trace mineral premixes is improved when using metal specific amino acid complexes compared to inorganic trace mineral sources. More liberal safety margins for vitamins may be needed when formulating vitamin-trace mineral premixes using inorganic sources of trace minerals.

KW - Complexes

KW - Pigs

KW - Premixes

KW - Trace minerals

KW - Vitamin stability

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=78951469510&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=78951469510&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.anifeedsci.2010.11.001

DO - 10.1016/j.anifeedsci.2010.11.001

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:78951469510

VL - 163

SP - 200

EP - 206

JO - Animal Feed Science and Technology

JF - Animal Feed Science and Technology

SN - 0377-8401

IS - 2-4

ER -