Discriminative Ratio of Spectral Power and Relative Power Features Derived via Frequency-Domain Model Ratio with Application to Seizure Prediction

Keshab K Parhi, Zisheng Zhang

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

The ratio of spectral power in two different bands and relative band power have been shown to be sometimes more discriminative features than the spectral power in a specific band for binary classification of a time series for seizure prediction. However, why and which ratio of spectral power and relative power features are better discriminators than a band power have not been understood. While general answers to why and which are difficult, this paper partially addresses the answer to these questions. Using auto-regressive modeling, this paper, for the first time, theoretically explains that for high signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) cases, the ratio features may sometime amplify the discriminability of one of the two states in a time series, as compared with a band power. This paper, also for the first time, introduces a novel frequency-domain model ratio (FDMR) that can be used to select the two frequency bands. The FDMR computes the ratio of the frequency responses of the two auto-regressive model filters that correspond to two different states. It is shown that the ratio implicitly cancels the effect of change of variance of the white noise that is input to the auto-regressive model in a non-stationary environment for high SNR conditions. It is also shown that under certain sufficient but not necessary conditions, the ratio of the spectral power and the relative band power, i.e., the band power divided by the total power spectral density, can be better discriminators than band power. Synthesized data and scalp EEG data from the MIT Physionet for patient-specific seizure prediction are used to explain why the ratios of spectral power obtained by a ranking algorithm in the prior literature satisfy the sufficient conditions for amplification of the ratio feature derived in this paper.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Article number8716296
Pages (from-to)645-657
Number of pages13
JournalIEEE transactions on biomedical circuits and systems
Volume13
Issue number4
DOIs
StatePublished - Aug 1 2019

Fingerprint

Discriminators
Time series
Signal to noise ratio
Power spectral density
White noise
Electroencephalography
Frequency bands
Frequency response
Amplification

Keywords

  • Time-series
  • auto-regressive model
  • classification
  • discriminability
  • frequency-domain model ratio (FDMR)
  • prediction error filter
  • ratio of band power
  • relative band power
  • seizure prediction

PubMed: MeSH publication types

  • Journal Article

Cite this

@article{78701e2835d54feab1933d521d9e6887,
title = "Discriminative Ratio of Spectral Power and Relative Power Features Derived via Frequency-Domain Model Ratio with Application to Seizure Prediction",
abstract = "The ratio of spectral power in two different bands and relative band power have been shown to be sometimes more discriminative features than the spectral power in a specific band for binary classification of a time series for seizure prediction. However, why and which ratio of spectral power and relative power features are better discriminators than a band power have not been understood. While general answers to why and which are difficult, this paper partially addresses the answer to these questions. Using auto-regressive modeling, this paper, for the first time, theoretically explains that for high signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) cases, the ratio features may sometime amplify the discriminability of one of the two states in a time series, as compared with a band power. This paper, also for the first time, introduces a novel frequency-domain model ratio (FDMR) that can be used to select the two frequency bands. The FDMR computes the ratio of the frequency responses of the two auto-regressive model filters that correspond to two different states. It is shown that the ratio implicitly cancels the effect of change of variance of the white noise that is input to the auto-regressive model in a non-stationary environment for high SNR conditions. It is also shown that under certain sufficient but not necessary conditions, the ratio of the spectral power and the relative band power, i.e., the band power divided by the total power spectral density, can be better discriminators than band power. Synthesized data and scalp EEG data from the MIT Physionet for patient-specific seizure prediction are used to explain why the ratios of spectral power obtained by a ranking algorithm in the prior literature satisfy the sufficient conditions for amplification of the ratio feature derived in this paper.",
keywords = "Time-series, auto-regressive model, classification, discriminability, frequency-domain model ratio (FDMR), prediction error filter, ratio of band power, relative band power, seizure prediction",
author = "Parhi, {Keshab K} and Zisheng Zhang",
year = "2019",
month = "8",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1109/TBCAS.2019.2917184",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "13",
pages = "645--657",
journal = "IEEE Transactions on Biomedical Circuits and Systems",
issn = "1932-4545",
publisher = "Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers Inc.",
number = "4",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Discriminative Ratio of Spectral Power and Relative Power Features Derived via Frequency-Domain Model Ratio with Application to Seizure Prediction

AU - Parhi, Keshab K

AU - Zhang, Zisheng

PY - 2019/8/1

Y1 - 2019/8/1

N2 - The ratio of spectral power in two different bands and relative band power have been shown to be sometimes more discriminative features than the spectral power in a specific band for binary classification of a time series for seizure prediction. However, why and which ratio of spectral power and relative power features are better discriminators than a band power have not been understood. While general answers to why and which are difficult, this paper partially addresses the answer to these questions. Using auto-regressive modeling, this paper, for the first time, theoretically explains that for high signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) cases, the ratio features may sometime amplify the discriminability of one of the two states in a time series, as compared with a band power. This paper, also for the first time, introduces a novel frequency-domain model ratio (FDMR) that can be used to select the two frequency bands. The FDMR computes the ratio of the frequency responses of the two auto-regressive model filters that correspond to two different states. It is shown that the ratio implicitly cancels the effect of change of variance of the white noise that is input to the auto-regressive model in a non-stationary environment for high SNR conditions. It is also shown that under certain sufficient but not necessary conditions, the ratio of the spectral power and the relative band power, i.e., the band power divided by the total power spectral density, can be better discriminators than band power. Synthesized data and scalp EEG data from the MIT Physionet for patient-specific seizure prediction are used to explain why the ratios of spectral power obtained by a ranking algorithm in the prior literature satisfy the sufficient conditions for amplification of the ratio feature derived in this paper.

AB - The ratio of spectral power in two different bands and relative band power have been shown to be sometimes more discriminative features than the spectral power in a specific band for binary classification of a time series for seizure prediction. However, why and which ratio of spectral power and relative power features are better discriminators than a band power have not been understood. While general answers to why and which are difficult, this paper partially addresses the answer to these questions. Using auto-regressive modeling, this paper, for the first time, theoretically explains that for high signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) cases, the ratio features may sometime amplify the discriminability of one of the two states in a time series, as compared with a band power. This paper, also for the first time, introduces a novel frequency-domain model ratio (FDMR) that can be used to select the two frequency bands. The FDMR computes the ratio of the frequency responses of the two auto-regressive model filters that correspond to two different states. It is shown that the ratio implicitly cancels the effect of change of variance of the white noise that is input to the auto-regressive model in a non-stationary environment for high SNR conditions. It is also shown that under certain sufficient but not necessary conditions, the ratio of the spectral power and the relative band power, i.e., the band power divided by the total power spectral density, can be better discriminators than band power. Synthesized data and scalp EEG data from the MIT Physionet for patient-specific seizure prediction are used to explain why the ratios of spectral power obtained by a ranking algorithm in the prior literature satisfy the sufficient conditions for amplification of the ratio feature derived in this paper.

KW - Time-series

KW - auto-regressive model

KW - classification

KW - discriminability

KW - frequency-domain model ratio (FDMR)

KW - prediction error filter

KW - ratio of band power

KW - relative band power

KW - seizure prediction

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85070945381&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85070945381&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1109/TBCAS.2019.2917184

DO - 10.1109/TBCAS.2019.2917184

M3 - Article

C2 - 31095498

AN - SCOPUS:85070945381

VL - 13

SP - 645

EP - 657

JO - IEEE Transactions on Biomedical Circuits and Systems

JF - IEEE Transactions on Biomedical Circuits and Systems

SN - 1932-4545

IS - 4

M1 - 8716296

ER -