Debating Somali identity in a British tribunal: The case of the BBC Somali service

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Some scholarly works and policy writings have conflated the old notion of cultural identity with the more recent politization of ethnicity. One of the best cases where cultural traditions have been confounded with political dispositions is Somalia. The country that was once considered Africa's nation-state par excellence is now dubbed a society deeply divided along clan lines. Genealogy is said to determine any Somali's political orientation. Political ethnicity appears triumphant in Somalia, as a coalition of warlords and donors have agreed to restructure the country into a federation of clans. This essay challenges this stream of thought and practice by arguing that blood alone has not been the only factor defining Somali identity. Instead, language, religion, custom, genealogy, and mode of livelihood mutually constitute identity. The article reports on a British court case that considered the nature of Somali identity. Advocates of political ethnicity argued that a Somali's political outlook is determined at birth by his or her genealogy. Conversely, those influenced by a social constructionist view disputed the claim that one's genealogical pedigree preordains one's political outlook. The latter warns about the dangers of blood-based politics, as in Rwanda.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)40-73
Number of pages34
JournalArab World Geographer
Volume9
Issue number1
StatePublished - Mar 1 2006

Fingerprint

genealogy
BBC
ethnicity
Somalia
blood
warlord
cultural tradition
cultural identity
Rwanda
nation state
political attitude
religion
federation
disposition
livelihood
coalition
politics
Religion
language
services

Keywords

  • Colonial anthropology
  • Critical social sciences
  • Ethnic politics
  • Genealogy
  • Political identity
  • Somali identity
  • Somalia

Cite this

Debating Somali identity in a British tribunal : The case of the BBC Somali service. / Samatar, Abdi I.

In: Arab World Geographer, Vol. 9, No. 1, 01.03.2006, p. 40-73.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{b84ae42716d24ecc856abdb85ab6a51a,
title = "Debating Somali identity in a British tribunal: The case of the BBC Somali service",
abstract = "Some scholarly works and policy writings have conflated the old notion of cultural identity with the more recent politization of ethnicity. One of the best cases where cultural traditions have been confounded with political dispositions is Somalia. The country that was once considered Africa's nation-state par excellence is now dubbed a society deeply divided along clan lines. Genealogy is said to determine any Somali's political orientation. Political ethnicity appears triumphant in Somalia, as a coalition of warlords and donors have agreed to restructure the country into a federation of clans. This essay challenges this stream of thought and practice by arguing that blood alone has not been the only factor defining Somali identity. Instead, language, religion, custom, genealogy, and mode of livelihood mutually constitute identity. The article reports on a British court case that considered the nature of Somali identity. Advocates of political ethnicity argued that a Somali's political outlook is determined at birth by his or her genealogy. Conversely, those influenced by a social constructionist view disputed the claim that one's genealogical pedigree preordains one's political outlook. The latter warns about the dangers of blood-based politics, as in Rwanda.",
keywords = "Colonial anthropology, Critical social sciences, Ethnic politics, Genealogy, Political identity, Somali identity, Somalia",
author = "Samatar, {Abdi I}",
year = "2006",
month = "3",
day = "1",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "9",
pages = "40--73",
journal = "Arab World Geographer",
issn = "1480-6800",
publisher = "University of Akron",
number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Debating Somali identity in a British tribunal

T2 - The case of the BBC Somali service

AU - Samatar, Abdi I

PY - 2006/3/1

Y1 - 2006/3/1

N2 - Some scholarly works and policy writings have conflated the old notion of cultural identity with the more recent politization of ethnicity. One of the best cases where cultural traditions have been confounded with political dispositions is Somalia. The country that was once considered Africa's nation-state par excellence is now dubbed a society deeply divided along clan lines. Genealogy is said to determine any Somali's political orientation. Political ethnicity appears triumphant in Somalia, as a coalition of warlords and donors have agreed to restructure the country into a federation of clans. This essay challenges this stream of thought and practice by arguing that blood alone has not been the only factor defining Somali identity. Instead, language, religion, custom, genealogy, and mode of livelihood mutually constitute identity. The article reports on a British court case that considered the nature of Somali identity. Advocates of political ethnicity argued that a Somali's political outlook is determined at birth by his or her genealogy. Conversely, those influenced by a social constructionist view disputed the claim that one's genealogical pedigree preordains one's political outlook. The latter warns about the dangers of blood-based politics, as in Rwanda.

AB - Some scholarly works and policy writings have conflated the old notion of cultural identity with the more recent politization of ethnicity. One of the best cases where cultural traditions have been confounded with political dispositions is Somalia. The country that was once considered Africa's nation-state par excellence is now dubbed a society deeply divided along clan lines. Genealogy is said to determine any Somali's political orientation. Political ethnicity appears triumphant in Somalia, as a coalition of warlords and donors have agreed to restructure the country into a federation of clans. This essay challenges this stream of thought and practice by arguing that blood alone has not been the only factor defining Somali identity. Instead, language, religion, custom, genealogy, and mode of livelihood mutually constitute identity. The article reports on a British court case that considered the nature of Somali identity. Advocates of political ethnicity argued that a Somali's political outlook is determined at birth by his or her genealogy. Conversely, those influenced by a social constructionist view disputed the claim that one's genealogical pedigree preordains one's political outlook. The latter warns about the dangers of blood-based politics, as in Rwanda.

KW - Colonial anthropology

KW - Critical social sciences

KW - Ethnic politics

KW - Genealogy

KW - Political identity

KW - Somali identity

KW - Somalia

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=34047130873&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=34047130873&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:34047130873

VL - 9

SP - 40

EP - 73

JO - Arab World Geographer

JF - Arab World Geographer

SN - 1480-6800

IS - 1

ER -