Classroom management for ethnic-racial minority students: A meta-analysis of single-case design studies

Anna C.J. Long, Faith G Miller, James J. Upright

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Diversification trends of U.S. schools make clear the need for evidence-based practices supporting ethnically-racially diverse students. Yet, there are significant hindrances to readily identifying and summarizing findings generated from diverse classroom contexts. The current meta-analytic review was designed to address this gap in the classroom management literature. This review includes single-case design studies conducted in majority ethnic-racial minority classrooms (≥50%) that included a direct comparison of baseline to treatment for behavior management strategies implemented at the whole class level. A total of 22 studies spanning from 1973 to 2014 met eligibility criteria for this review, including 838 students and 46 K-12 classrooms. Results indicate that classwide management approaches applied in diverse classrooms are heavily behavioral and highly effective in improving student behavior (Mτ = |.92|, MHedges's g = 2.52). Overall, interventions that included an individual or group contingency consistently demonstrated large effects and were the most frequently used strategies. However, other interventions displayed comparably high results but were less frequently studied. Findings further revealed significant gaps in the quality and diversity of research completed to date. Specifically, half of the studies did not include cases that met What Works Clearinghouse design standards for demonstrating methodological rigor. There were also few studies that included minority populations other than African American, and there was limited variation in educational settings and intervention designs. Of some concern was the heightened frequency of response cost procedures included in interventions for diverse classrooms, possibly running counter to recommendations that emphasize reinforcement-based strategies.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)1-13
Number of pages13
JournalSchool Psychology Quarterly
Volume34
Issue number1
DOIs
StatePublished - Jan 1 2019

Fingerprint

Meta-Analysis
minority
Students
classroom
management
student
Evidence-Based Practice
African Americans
ethnic structure
Costs and Cost Analysis
educational setting
Research
reinforcement
diversification
contingency
Population
Therapeutics
trend
costs
school

Keywords

  • Behavior
  • Classroom management
  • Diversity
  • Minority
  • Review

PubMed: MeSH publication types

  • Journal Article
  • Meta-Analysis

Cite this

Classroom management for ethnic-racial minority students : A meta-analysis of single-case design studies. / Long, Anna C.J.; Miller, Faith G; Upright, James J.

In: School Psychology Quarterly, Vol. 34, No. 1, 01.01.2019, p. 1-13.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

@article{30497167496247ec9bd431bcf47e5cd1,
title = "Classroom management for ethnic-racial minority students: A meta-analysis of single-case design studies",
abstract = "Diversification trends of U.S. schools make clear the need for evidence-based practices supporting ethnically-racially diverse students. Yet, there are significant hindrances to readily identifying and summarizing findings generated from diverse classroom contexts. The current meta-analytic review was designed to address this gap in the classroom management literature. This review includes single-case design studies conducted in majority ethnic-racial minority classrooms (≥50{\%}) that included a direct comparison of baseline to treatment for behavior management strategies implemented at the whole class level. A total of 22 studies spanning from 1973 to 2014 met eligibility criteria for this review, including 838 students and 46 K-12 classrooms. Results indicate that classwide management approaches applied in diverse classrooms are heavily behavioral and highly effective in improving student behavior (Mτ = |.92|, MHedges's g = 2.52). Overall, interventions that included an individual or group contingency consistently demonstrated large effects and were the most frequently used strategies. However, other interventions displayed comparably high results but were less frequently studied. Findings further revealed significant gaps in the quality and diversity of research completed to date. Specifically, half of the studies did not include cases that met What Works Clearinghouse design standards for demonstrating methodological rigor. There were also few studies that included minority populations other than African American, and there was limited variation in educational settings and intervention designs. Of some concern was the heightened frequency of response cost procedures included in interventions for diverse classrooms, possibly running counter to recommendations that emphasize reinforcement-based strategies.",
keywords = "Behavior, Classroom management, Diversity, Minority, Review",
author = "Long, {Anna C.J.} and Miller, {Faith G} and Upright, {James J.}",
year = "2019",
month = "1",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1037/spq0000305",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "34",
pages = "1--13",
journal = "School Psychology",
issn = "2578-4218",
publisher = "American Psychological Association",
number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Classroom management for ethnic-racial minority students

T2 - A meta-analysis of single-case design studies

AU - Long, Anna C.J.

AU - Miller, Faith G

AU - Upright, James J.

PY - 2019/1/1

Y1 - 2019/1/1

N2 - Diversification trends of U.S. schools make clear the need for evidence-based practices supporting ethnically-racially diverse students. Yet, there are significant hindrances to readily identifying and summarizing findings generated from diverse classroom contexts. The current meta-analytic review was designed to address this gap in the classroom management literature. This review includes single-case design studies conducted in majority ethnic-racial minority classrooms (≥50%) that included a direct comparison of baseline to treatment for behavior management strategies implemented at the whole class level. A total of 22 studies spanning from 1973 to 2014 met eligibility criteria for this review, including 838 students and 46 K-12 classrooms. Results indicate that classwide management approaches applied in diverse classrooms are heavily behavioral and highly effective in improving student behavior (Mτ = |.92|, MHedges's g = 2.52). Overall, interventions that included an individual or group contingency consistently demonstrated large effects and were the most frequently used strategies. However, other interventions displayed comparably high results but were less frequently studied. Findings further revealed significant gaps in the quality and diversity of research completed to date. Specifically, half of the studies did not include cases that met What Works Clearinghouse design standards for demonstrating methodological rigor. There were also few studies that included minority populations other than African American, and there was limited variation in educational settings and intervention designs. Of some concern was the heightened frequency of response cost procedures included in interventions for diverse classrooms, possibly running counter to recommendations that emphasize reinforcement-based strategies.

AB - Diversification trends of U.S. schools make clear the need for evidence-based practices supporting ethnically-racially diverse students. Yet, there are significant hindrances to readily identifying and summarizing findings generated from diverse classroom contexts. The current meta-analytic review was designed to address this gap in the classroom management literature. This review includes single-case design studies conducted in majority ethnic-racial minority classrooms (≥50%) that included a direct comparison of baseline to treatment for behavior management strategies implemented at the whole class level. A total of 22 studies spanning from 1973 to 2014 met eligibility criteria for this review, including 838 students and 46 K-12 classrooms. Results indicate that classwide management approaches applied in diverse classrooms are heavily behavioral and highly effective in improving student behavior (Mτ = |.92|, MHedges's g = 2.52). Overall, interventions that included an individual or group contingency consistently demonstrated large effects and were the most frequently used strategies. However, other interventions displayed comparably high results but were less frequently studied. Findings further revealed significant gaps in the quality and diversity of research completed to date. Specifically, half of the studies did not include cases that met What Works Clearinghouse design standards for demonstrating methodological rigor. There were also few studies that included minority populations other than African American, and there was limited variation in educational settings and intervention designs. Of some concern was the heightened frequency of response cost procedures included in interventions for diverse classrooms, possibly running counter to recommendations that emphasize reinforcement-based strategies.

KW - Behavior

KW - Classroom management

KW - Diversity

KW - Minority

KW - Review

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85058864914&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85058864914&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1037/spq0000305

DO - 10.1037/spq0000305

M3 - Article

C2 - 30570288

AN - SCOPUS:85058864914

VL - 34

SP - 1

EP - 13

JO - School Psychology

JF - School Psychology

SN - 2578-4218

IS - 1

ER -