A comparison of freshwater mussel assemblages along a land-use gradient in Minnesota

Daniel J. Hornbach, Mark C. Hove, Kelly R. MacGregor, Jessica L. Kozarek, Bernard E. Sietman, Mike Davis

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Intensive agricultural land use may have adverse impacts on freshwater mussel assemblages. Before European settlement, the Minnesota River Basin (MRB) was home to dense and diverse assemblages of freshwater mussels. Of the 40 species that occurred there, 43% have been extirpated. the St. Croix Basin (SCB) in Minnesota/Wisconsin, in contrast, has maintained a dense and diverse mussel assemblage, probably owing to the maintenance of a higher-quality ecosystem. Mussels were sampled in four rivers representing an agricultural land-use gradient. Timed searches were conducted in each of three rivers of the MRB, and in one river in the SCB in 2015. These were previously sampled by the Minnesota Department of Natural Resources (1998–2008). Mussel abundance and richness were lower in the MRB compared with the SCB. There were negligible changes in mussel density in the SCB, whereas abundances declined 17–83% in the MRB over the same period. Rates of decline were greatest for rivers with higher agricultural land use. Individuals of species that inhabited both basins were larger in tributaries with higher agricultural land use. MRB rivers with increased agricultural land use harboured a greater proportion of individuals displaying opportunistic (low life-span, age and high fecundity) and periodic life-history traits (moderate to high growth rates, low to intermediate fecundity, life span and age at maturity), whereas SCB assemblages had a greater percentage of mussels displaying equilibrium life-history traits (long life-span, late maturity and low reproductive effort). Also, rivers with higher amounts of suspended sediment contained more individuals classified as disturbance tolerant. This study provides evidence that agricultural land use contributes to the loss of mussel diversity and abundance, especially in mussel species that are long lived or slow to reproduce. These life-history traits may be correlated with increased sensitivity to disturbances commonly observed in agricultural basins, including more and larger flood events.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)1826-1838
Number of pages13
JournalAquatic Conservation: Marine and Freshwater Ecosystems
Volume29
Issue number11
DOIs
StatePublished - Nov 1 2019

Fingerprint

mussels
land use
agricultural land
river basin
basins
basin
life history trait
river
rivers
fecundity
life history
disturbance
age at maturity
reproductive effort
comparison
suspended sediment
tributary
natural resource
natural resources
ecosystem

Keywords

  • agricultural impact
  • disturbance tolerance
  • life-history traits
  • suspended sediment

Cite this

A comparison of freshwater mussel assemblages along a land-use gradient in Minnesota. / Hornbach, Daniel J.; Hove, Mark C.; MacGregor, Kelly R.; Kozarek, Jessica L.; Sietman, Bernard E.; Davis, Mike.

In: Aquatic Conservation: Marine and Freshwater Ecosystems, Vol. 29, No. 11, 01.11.2019, p. 1826-1838.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Hornbach, Daniel J. ; Hove, Mark C. ; MacGregor, Kelly R. ; Kozarek, Jessica L. ; Sietman, Bernard E. ; Davis, Mike. / A comparison of freshwater mussel assemblages along a land-use gradient in Minnesota. In: Aquatic Conservation: Marine and Freshwater Ecosystems. 2019 ; Vol. 29, No. 11. pp. 1826-1838.
@article{fe1308c5cb08400ab6a19f1ed39f7000,
title = "A comparison of freshwater mussel assemblages along a land-use gradient in Minnesota",
abstract = "Intensive agricultural land use may have adverse impacts on freshwater mussel assemblages. Before European settlement, the Minnesota River Basin (MRB) was home to dense and diverse assemblages of freshwater mussels. Of the 40 species that occurred there, 43{\%} have been extirpated. the St. Croix Basin (SCB) in Minnesota/Wisconsin, in contrast, has maintained a dense and diverse mussel assemblage, probably owing to the maintenance of a higher-quality ecosystem. Mussels were sampled in four rivers representing an agricultural land-use gradient. Timed searches were conducted in each of three rivers of the MRB, and in one river in the SCB in 2015. These were previously sampled by the Minnesota Department of Natural Resources (1998–2008). Mussel abundance and richness were lower in the MRB compared with the SCB. There were negligible changes in mussel density in the SCB, whereas abundances declined 17–83{\%} in the MRB over the same period. Rates of decline were greatest for rivers with higher agricultural land use. Individuals of species that inhabited both basins were larger in tributaries with higher agricultural land use. MRB rivers with increased agricultural land use harboured a greater proportion of individuals displaying opportunistic (low life-span, age and high fecundity) and periodic life-history traits (moderate to high growth rates, low to intermediate fecundity, life span and age at maturity), whereas SCB assemblages had a greater percentage of mussels displaying equilibrium life-history traits (long life-span, late maturity and low reproductive effort). Also, rivers with higher amounts of suspended sediment contained more individuals classified as disturbance tolerant. This study provides evidence that agricultural land use contributes to the loss of mussel diversity and abundance, especially in mussel species that are long lived or slow to reproduce. These life-history traits may be correlated with increased sensitivity to disturbances commonly observed in agricultural basins, including more and larger flood events.",
keywords = "agricultural impact, disturbance tolerance, life-history traits, suspended sediment",
author = "Hornbach, {Daniel J.} and Hove, {Mark C.} and MacGregor, {Kelly R.} and Kozarek, {Jessica L.} and Sietman, {Bernard E.} and Mike Davis",
year = "2019",
month = "11",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1002/aqc.3167",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "29",
pages = "1826--1838",
journal = "Aquatic Conservation: Marine and Freshwater Ecosystems",
issn = "1052-7613",
publisher = "John Wiley and Sons Ltd",
number = "11",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - A comparison of freshwater mussel assemblages along a land-use gradient in Minnesota

AU - Hornbach, Daniel J.

AU - Hove, Mark C.

AU - MacGregor, Kelly R.

AU - Kozarek, Jessica L.

AU - Sietman, Bernard E.

AU - Davis, Mike

PY - 2019/11/1

Y1 - 2019/11/1

N2 - Intensive agricultural land use may have adverse impacts on freshwater mussel assemblages. Before European settlement, the Minnesota River Basin (MRB) was home to dense and diverse assemblages of freshwater mussels. Of the 40 species that occurred there, 43% have been extirpated. the St. Croix Basin (SCB) in Minnesota/Wisconsin, in contrast, has maintained a dense and diverse mussel assemblage, probably owing to the maintenance of a higher-quality ecosystem. Mussels were sampled in four rivers representing an agricultural land-use gradient. Timed searches were conducted in each of three rivers of the MRB, and in one river in the SCB in 2015. These were previously sampled by the Minnesota Department of Natural Resources (1998–2008). Mussel abundance and richness were lower in the MRB compared with the SCB. There were negligible changes in mussel density in the SCB, whereas abundances declined 17–83% in the MRB over the same period. Rates of decline were greatest for rivers with higher agricultural land use. Individuals of species that inhabited both basins were larger in tributaries with higher agricultural land use. MRB rivers with increased agricultural land use harboured a greater proportion of individuals displaying opportunistic (low life-span, age and high fecundity) and periodic life-history traits (moderate to high growth rates, low to intermediate fecundity, life span and age at maturity), whereas SCB assemblages had a greater percentage of mussels displaying equilibrium life-history traits (long life-span, late maturity and low reproductive effort). Also, rivers with higher amounts of suspended sediment contained more individuals classified as disturbance tolerant. This study provides evidence that agricultural land use contributes to the loss of mussel diversity and abundance, especially in mussel species that are long lived or slow to reproduce. These life-history traits may be correlated with increased sensitivity to disturbances commonly observed in agricultural basins, including more and larger flood events.

AB - Intensive agricultural land use may have adverse impacts on freshwater mussel assemblages. Before European settlement, the Minnesota River Basin (MRB) was home to dense and diverse assemblages of freshwater mussels. Of the 40 species that occurred there, 43% have been extirpated. the St. Croix Basin (SCB) in Minnesota/Wisconsin, in contrast, has maintained a dense and diverse mussel assemblage, probably owing to the maintenance of a higher-quality ecosystem. Mussels were sampled in four rivers representing an agricultural land-use gradient. Timed searches were conducted in each of three rivers of the MRB, and in one river in the SCB in 2015. These were previously sampled by the Minnesota Department of Natural Resources (1998–2008). Mussel abundance and richness were lower in the MRB compared with the SCB. There were negligible changes in mussel density in the SCB, whereas abundances declined 17–83% in the MRB over the same period. Rates of decline were greatest for rivers with higher agricultural land use. Individuals of species that inhabited both basins were larger in tributaries with higher agricultural land use. MRB rivers with increased agricultural land use harboured a greater proportion of individuals displaying opportunistic (low life-span, age and high fecundity) and periodic life-history traits (moderate to high growth rates, low to intermediate fecundity, life span and age at maturity), whereas SCB assemblages had a greater percentage of mussels displaying equilibrium life-history traits (long life-span, late maturity and low reproductive effort). Also, rivers with higher amounts of suspended sediment contained more individuals classified as disturbance tolerant. This study provides evidence that agricultural land use contributes to the loss of mussel diversity and abundance, especially in mussel species that are long lived or slow to reproduce. These life-history traits may be correlated with increased sensitivity to disturbances commonly observed in agricultural basins, including more and larger flood events.

KW - agricultural impact

KW - disturbance tolerance

KW - life-history traits

KW - suspended sediment

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85069845732&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85069845732&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1002/aqc.3167

DO - 10.1002/aqc.3167

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:85069845732

VL - 29

SP - 1826

EP - 1838

JO - Aquatic Conservation: Marine and Freshwater Ecosystems

JF - Aquatic Conservation: Marine and Freshwater Ecosystems

SN - 1052-7613

IS - 11

ER -